Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
64 of 79 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A half-fictional work disguised as a historiography, November 20, 2002
YES - The essential facts put forward by Baldwin are correct: Ford was a major anti-semite and he gave money to the German Nazis, helping them into power.Yet, Baldwin's research is pathetic... a great deal of it was his imagination. He fails to present facts put forward by Kurt Ludecke's I KNEW HITLER; or Bennett's WE NEVER CALLED HIM HENRY; with any accuracy - he simply makes up what he wants. For example, Baldwin states that the day after Nazi fund raiser Kurt Ludecke visited Ford, and Ludecke was turned away, a telegram to Lukecke arrived the NEXT DAY stating that Ford wouldn't give money through Ludecke to Hitler. Yet - READ Ludecke's I KNEW HITLER - the only primary source available on Ludecke/Ford. In this ONLY first hand account, Ludecke writes that several WEEKS (not ONE day) passed between his meeting with Ford and arrival of the telegram in question. Baldwin has failed here as he does throughout the book to provide an accurate account of events. He makes no mention of the difference in Ludecke's primary source account and his own secondary account. Baldwin has shown himself as incompetent. I have researched this subject for over 2 years. Baldwin makes a
serious error on virtually every page. His errors show an incredible degree of sloppy research. He seems to have only half-read his sources. His book is a joke as a serious work on Ford, anti-semitism, German inter-war history, and Hitler A far, far, better book is Albert Lee's Henry Ford and the Jews (1980). Interestingly, in the forward of Baldwin's book he writes that he put Lee's book (the one with the SAME title which inspired him) on the "shelf" while writing his book. YET, he quotes Albert Lee's: Henry Ford And The Jews, often throughout his book. How on the shelf could that book have been, since he was citing it so often? Baldwin is a professor of poetry, not a historian, and his lack of understanding of the sort of research that goes into such a work is evident to anyone who has bothered to read the sources he cites. Baldwin constantly takes liberties; invents events that didn't happen; embellishes, and novelizes. He fails to demonstrate that his work is anything but the work of someone who should stay with what he has done very well in the past: writing books on poetry. This is, bottom line, an appallingly ill-researched book - one of the worst I've ever seen that claims to be a serious work. The only thing good that can be said about this book is that it helped to bring Henry Ford's support of anti-semitism, Nazis and so forth to the public's attention - but that is all. If the material were not so important to discuss, I would give this book 1 star. As it is, I give it 2 because he did make an attempt (albeit pathetic, as it is) to take on a very hot subject. Again... the broad facts in Baldwin's book are very correct, but the specifics are nearly all wrong. Baldwin wrote a historical fiction novel masquarading as a historiograhy. Bottom line: get Albert Lee's Henry Ford and the Jews (1980) instead of this ill-researched "novel."
|
|
|
74 of 97 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Always Necessary, December 6, 2001
History must be revised when any new and accurate information appears. Neil Baldwin's book, "Henry Ford And The Jews The Mass Production Of Hate", utilizes some information that was only opened from archives in March of 2001. Further, no matter how much time may pass, history as portrayed in this book must always be available to new generations of readers. I believe that the darker aspects of this country's or any nation's history, must be documented accurately and fairly. Reality has demonstrated that with the passage of time facts are forgotten, and become the target for revisionists who replace history with fiction. Historical events like The Holocaust have been defended in court within the last 2 years. The defense was required to prove The Holocaust took place.Mr. Baldwin has documented the actions of one of the most influential businessmen of the 20th Century. Mr. Henry Ford's achievements in the production of his cars are a fact of history. Mr. Ford was a talented man, and had he confined himself to what he was competent to conduct, his memory would be a very different one. Mr. Ford is portrayed in this book by a wide variety of sources as a man who was amazingly ill informed, a man who placed no value on education, was a tyrant to those who made his fortune, and a man who had the distinction of having his portrait on the wall of Adolph Hitler's Office. Like other notable names in American History he accepted the highest honor bestowed on a non-German by Hitler. Another recipient Charles Lindbergh could claim he had no idea he was to be presented with the, "Honor". Mr. Ford accepted his on the occasion of his birthday with 1500 invited guests. Another famous recipient of the award was Mr. Thomas Watson of IBM fame. Of the 3 men, only the latter had the common sense to return the medal. Mr. Ford proudly stood for photographs of his presentation on July 30, 1938. At this point there is no conceivable defense for claiming not to know what Hitler was about. Mr. Ford claimed to hate those who were profiteers of war. His views changed as Ford operated in Germany throughout World War II producing tens of thousands of military trucks and cars, and unlike other companies, Ford was never nationalized, and retained majority ownership throughout the war. As the Nazi's invaded other nations they handed the production of cars over to Ford. It helps to bring the idea of how influential this man was forward in time. Today you would need to take the head of one of the world's largest companies, and then imagine his conducting himself as Ford did. Today it is inconceivable that a person could buy a newspaper for the express purpose of spreading Anti-Semitic hatred, that a person could publish countless thousands of copies of, "The Protocols Of The Elders Of Zion", and continue to claim they were anything but the fiction they were. But this is what he did, for decades. He continually tried to force anyone who bought one of his cars to buy a subscription to his paper; he demanded that dealers tie his anti-Semitism to every sale. Mr. Ford is often spoken of when better wages are discussed during his period in manufacturing history. What I had not read before was the private portion of the company that would inspect the homes and personal habits of workers to qualify them for this added pay. A worker was subject to any invasion of privacy to ensure he lived, as Ford deemed appropriate. Henry Ford never did anything that was not in his interest, and was not tangled in strings for those who would accept his "largesse". The author was catalyzed to pursue this subject when The Ford Motor Company underwrote all the funds that would have been generated by selling commercials when, "Schindler's List", was first aired on television. This is the new Ford Company that came about almost immediately upon the founder's death. The present company in no way should be blamed for the sins of its founder, however after half a century has passed, the need to make amends is clearly still felt. The book tells a tragic story of events that took place not so long ago. Events that will always be relevant, should always be available, and never forgotten.
|
|
|
28 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A compelling account of how a great american duped us all!, December 3, 2001
By A Customer
I couldn't put this book down. I was raised thinking that Henry Ford was an average American guy who used sheer fortitude, hard work, and intuition to become what Forbes Magazine called the "Greatest Entrepreneur of the Century!" Little did I know that Ford's hate for the Jews permeated his life; his actions created an atmosphere for global Jew-hating that may have seeded Hitler's final solution. How many Americans know that Hitler hung a poster of Ford behind his desk, or that he coveted copies of Ford hate-rhetoric at the same time he was penning Mein Kampf? I can't be the only one who didn't know that Hitler actually presented Ford with a hero-worship medal, or that the German branch of Ford Comapny probably produced engines which were used against the Allies in W.W.II. This is a quick lesson in how money creates power, and how power prevents people from seeing through the thin veil of opportunism that is often a shield for prejudice. Ford was a person who knew how to run a business, even if it meant compromising the rights of employees; he worked for years to bust unions and he created a human resources area in the Ford company that spied on workers and fired them for "breaking" spoken and unspoken rules of conduct. I could go on and on quoting Baldwin's scholarship in revealing the unkindliness and evil of Henry Ford and the men who empowered him. There is a wealth of material in the book, much of it footnoted to ensure clarity. Sometimes I went to those footnotes, as I was curious about where specific information had come from. Time and time again, I was astonished at the range of research, and the author's ability to weave myraid sources and information into a compelling story. I am changed from reading the book. For example, I finally understand the political and social climate which existed both in the US and America during the time of Hitler's rise to power. It is also conceiveable to me now, how America stood by (for so long) as Jews were systematically killed; we stood by because American big business was "part of the problem". I also understand the ageless legacy of anti-semitism which has seeded continued world confusion about Judiasm: Race or Religion? If you are a student of the Holocaust, an American who wants to know the real story about one of our culture's "great" minds, read this book, and begin to understand the concept of revisionist history. How is it possible that Ford could have had a newspaper (The Dearbourn Independent) that committed itself to degredation of the Jews, less than a century ago, and that this could have been left out of this history books? Who kept it out of the history books? I thank Neil Baldwin for lifting the veil of ignorance our society has had about the life of Henry Ford. It's time that we respect Ford's wealth, and save our hero-worship for truly Americans, who recognize that diversity is what makes America great.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Edwin Black
by Steven Watts
See all Editorial Reviews
