|
|
12 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
It coulda been a contender, July 12, 2004
Having decided to film and produce a series of life history interviews with my grandmother before she passes, I figured it was high time the quality of my productions moved beyond elementary home movies. I purchased this book knowing full well that it was targeted towards the indie filmmaker rather than the serious hobbiest, so I expected portions of it to be irrelevant to me. Even with that expectation, I was disappointed with this book. There is some information in this book that could be very helpful. The author includes several example letters, contracts, release forms, and the like; however, the good parts are often lost in the jungle of his socio-economic views, anti-establishment diatribes, and self-promotion of his previous works. (If 'DYI or DIE' was intended to go hand in hand with the book, why not include the DVD and call it the '$35 Film School?') Furthermore, the author goes on at length on subjects better left to others while neglecting in-depth discussion in the areas where his experience is useful. For example, he devotes 150+ pages (nearly 1/3 of the book!) instructing the reader on how to do various things in Premiere, cinestream, Vegas, Acid, Soundforge, and MyDVD. Yet, when it comes to the actual camera work, lighting setups, audio engineering, or editing, too often he instructs the reader to "study films and figure out why they did that." I'm sitting here having just finished the book after several hours of reading, trying to think of the good sections. The only part that stands out is the very first chapter on writing screenplays. Sadly, the good part ends on page 14... that's where he devotes 1 3/4 pages telling the reader how to bind the screenplay with brads. I'm sure that 1 3/4 pages of "treeware" (his eco-friendly term) could have been used in a much more effective way. I also felt that the author spent far too much time (especially in the first 100 pages) justifying his actions and solitary working behavior. If he doesn't want to work with interns, that's okay. There is no need to write pages and pages on the inadequacies of film school students, interns, and volunteers who don't follow through. Make your point and move on. You might wonder why I spent several hours reading a book that I found so disappointing. I actually found the book fairly interesting (minus the software tutorials), just not particularly helpful. There are a few good things in there if you dig for them, but this book would have been much better and just as informative if it had been 100 pages instead of 465 pages. If you're looking for a book to teach you the technical aspects of filmmaking, move along. This book isn't it. If you're looking for a book to motivate you to finish that indie film that has been sitting in your attic for the past 9 years, this might be right up your alley.
|