Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
78 of 82 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Wasted Opportunity, November 8, 2008
Unlike most of the negative reviewers I'm not docking stars due to cost or length. I thought the description made it clear what Backup would be, so I did not feel deceived. This is however, the first of Butcher's books to get less than 4.5 stars from me, and surprisingly it is entirely due to characterization, writing and plotting.
Characterization - Thomas is awesome. His character arc has been great, and the scene with him, Harry, the race, and the water bottle from "Dead Beat" is probably my favorite of the series. So what do we learn about him now that we are in his head? Nothing new. Nothing about his relationship with his sister, his girlfriends, his clients or even his brother. Honestly, he seems less interesting and intelligent to me now than he did before.
Writing - Thomas's voice...is Harry's voice. Sure, different in some details, but the tone, the rhythms, the wise cracks, they were all Dresden-esque. Far more than genetics would be able to explain. I felt like it was lazy. You could have swapped Harry and Thomas's role in the story, and a significant amount of the internal dialog would not have had to be rewritten.
Plotting - So we get the first Dresden Files story from a non-Harry point of view. That's exciting, I can't wait to see what we learn that we haven't been able to see before. Who is in the story? Thomas, Lara, Justine, Mouse, Bob, Harry, Villian du jour. Not a particularly new cast of characters, eh? Where does the bulk of the exposition take place? Harry's basement, talking to Bob. Where do we go in the Dresden universe, Thomas's apartment and Harry's apartment. What do we learn about Harry from this new POV - he's noble, too trusting, and a really really powerful mage. There is a new major supernatural conspiracy, but it is unrelated to Harry, extremely non-time specific, not particularly threatening compared to most of Harry's cases, and is unlikely to show up again.
So all in all I was hugely disappointed. I expected to walk away from this novella with a different perspective on Thomas, Harry, their relationship, their priorities, the White Court, what it is like to be a Vampire-in-exile, something. But no, there wasn't anything new. That scene from Dead Beat I reference above did a much better job making me empathize with Thomas than every description (or illustration) of "His Demon" in Backup.
Was it awful, of course not. I enjoyed it in parts, and the humor was well done, but there wasn't anything there I'm going to take away with me.
|
|
|
27 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
From a monster's POV, October 23, 2008
I'll confess right up front that I am an unabashed fan of Thomas Raith, Harry Dresden's psy-vampire half-brother, and when I first heard about this book, I couldn't get my hands on it fast enough. As short as it is, it's a great read, and it gives the reader a glimpse into the mind of a character who is far more than the mere pretty face he may pretend to be. We get a first-hand sense of Thomas's struggle to keep his literal inner demon-symbiote in check, and of his concern for his little brother. And we also get some stunning if deceptively small revelations about the world in which they both live and work and fight to keep the things that go bump in the night in check. The illustrations by legendary graphic novel artist Mike Mignola more than complete this great little book!
|
|
|
37 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not a lot for the price, October 27, 2008
I have to admit I pre-ordered my Backup from Subterranean Press way back in January when it was announced at Bucher's site. Therefore, I was gouged the full $20, but even at the reduced Amazon price this is still overpriced.
I really felt it was a rip-off in many ways: The novella is actually 70 pages, NOT 80 as it has been listed. Even within that, there are MAYBE 55 actual pages of story (and even then it is a very small book in size so translated to regular HC or PB it would be even less), thanks to blank pages before chapter breaks and the Mignola illustrations (which are kinda "eh", they don't offer much).
An average Dresden Files book is about 400 pages in large HC format and usually you can get one for $15 around release thanks to Amazon pre-order pricing, so the fact that Backup was more expensive than a full Files books is just a joke.
People complained about "Welcome to the Jungle" because it was a Graphic Novel/Comic, but there is definitely more story and, I think, more text in that story than this one, not to mention the nice art and little extras at the end.
The story itself is good. I like Thomas, and being a fan of the Dresden books it was a nice supplementary tale. There is some good information about Thomas and "Oblivion War" that would never have been revealed in a Harry-centered tale, but it is (at least at this point) of no real consequence to the Dresden Files main story. If I was rating it just based on the story, I would have given it 4 star review, but unless you are a hardcore Dresden fan, it is NOT worth the price of admission.
Id recommend borrowing it from a friend for 40 minutes, that is about all it will take to read. Between this and the short-story anthologies, I am starting to feel a bit annoyed at the cost of minor side stories to the Dresden Files. $15 for this, $10 for a short story anthology (x4 now) with ONE minor Dresden tale, it is just too much for too little. Stick with the main Files books, they are worth the money.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Jim Butcher
by Jim Butcher
by Jim Butcher
See all Editorial Reviews
