Blood and Circumstance (Hardcover)

~ (Author)

Editorial Reviews

From Publishers Weekly

Reading like an offbeat criminal justice version of the talking-head film My Dinner with Andre, attorney Hollon's latest takes an intriguing look at the nature of mental capacity. The bulk of the novel consists of psychiatric sessions conducted in prison by Dr. Ellis Andrews with inmate Joel Stabler, accused of the murder of his brother, Danny. Joel's uncanny intelligence enables him to turn the tables on his interrogator, manipulating the doctor into empathizing with the accused, who claims that he took his sibling's life to spare Danny from the ravages of mental illness that devastated their father. The reliability of Joel's memories is called into question, leading to a satisfyingly ambiguous ending. The author's gift for understated dialogue makes the conversations between doctor and patient particularly compelling. (Jan.)
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.

From Booklist

A study in family dysfunction, this intense crime novel is told mainly through a series of interviews with prisoner Joel Stabler, who is being examined by a psychiatrist charged with determining whether Joel is fit to stand trial for murdering his brother. As Joel reveals the bleak circumstances under which he was raised by an ineffectual mother and a violent, mentally ill father, the highly observant prisoner also examines the doctor, gleaning information about his marital state and his evaluation notes. Highly intelligent, Joel tells a convincing story of being forced into the role of family caregiver at a very young age. According to Joel, his brother suffered all of his life from untreated bipolar disorder, and his murder was a mercy killing. But in the deftly executed conclusion of this unusual novel, everything Joel has spoken about is called into question. Although certain details (would Joel really know the work of Robert Penn Warren?) can seem jarring at times, breaking the carefully sustained mood, this is a chilling story full of unexpected twists and turns. Joanne Wilkinson
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

See all Editorial Reviews

Product Details

• Hardcover: 200 pages
• Publisher: MacAdam/Cage; 1ST edition (February 6, 2007)
• Language: English
• ISBN-10: 159692196X
• ISBN-13: 978-1596921962
• Product Dimensions: 8.1 x 5.2 x 0.9 inches
• Shipping Weight: 7.2 ounces (View shipping rates and policies)
• Average Customer Review: 5.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (4 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #1,470,121 in Books (See Bestsellers in Books)

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars Dark, disturbing, and memorable , February 8, 2007

By	Bookreporter.com (New York, New York) - See all my reviews

Quietly, Frank Turner Hollon has been building a body of quality work in the suspense genre, stretching and modifying the form of the novel not merely for experimental purposes but as a vehicle to further enhance the telling of the story. Hollon continues this practice in BLOOD AND CIRCUMSTANCE, arguably his darkest and most disturbing tale to date.

Almost the entirety of BLOOD AND CIRCUMSTANCE consists of a dialogue between Joel Stabler and Dr. Ellis Andrews. The context of their relationship is unfortunate and horrific. Stabler is incarcerated following the murder of his brother Danny in what appears to be a mercy killing occasioned by Danny's severe mental illness. Seeking a friendly, professional opinion, Stabler's attorneys retain Andrews for the purpose of performing a psychological evaluation to determine if Stabler is competent to stand trial.

Stabler presents as a near-genius, one who is observant, canny and well-read; he's also, if he is to be believed, the product of a household where he and his family were subjected to unthinkable physical and mental abuse. The transcript of the clinical interview between Stabler and Andrews reveals not only the depth and breadth of Stabler's intellect --- his IQ is off the charts and he quotes Walker Percy and Ralph Waldo Emerson at will --- but also a disturbed (and disturbing) view of the world.

Meanwhile, Andrews finds himself slowly losing control of the interview. Though the reader's perspective of Andrews is acquired almost entirely through this transcript and Stabler's own wry mental observations of him, the picture that is presented is of a man who has issues of his own. Andrews's point of view is not revealed until the novel's conclusion --- and even then, when Andrews learns the (possible) truth about his subject, more questions are raised than are ultimately answered.

What is fascinating about BLOOD AND CIRCUMSTANCE is that, in order to fully appreciate what has occurred between the covers of this disturbing tale, the reader should immediately re-read the entire novel in light of the revelations set forth in the conclusion. This is not an onerous task by any means, given the length of the book (178 pages). The brevity, however, belies the complexity and richness of the narrative, the depth of the enigma and the mystery it presents.

BLOOD AND CIRCUMSTANCE raises questions about divinity, morality, sanity and reality. There are no easy answers, but they will keep you awake long after you finish this memorable, disturbing work. If you're looking for a selection for your book club, make it this one. Highly recommended.

--- Reviewed by Joe Hartlaub

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars "You can't get away from your blood and my blood's poison.", February 8, 2007

By	Luan Gaines "luansos" (Dana Point, CA USA) - See all my reviews (TOP 100 REVIEWER)    (REAL NAME)

Hollon writes his novel on parallel tracks, seducing the reader with a tale that is heartbreaking, a young man raised in abuse who kills his younger brother to save him from the cycling ravages of mental illness. Joel Stabler is clear about his motives, uncharacteristically honest with the appointed forensic psychologist, Dr. Ellis Andrews. Through the course of the interview process, Joel explores the family that has formed him, a crazy abusive father, the brother, Danny, deteriorating rapidly, the youngest sister, Lisa, an innocent vessel of the family's hope. As Joel unravels the violence of his tragic childhood, he appeals to Dr. Ellis for some recognition of his long struggle, the sense of purpose he feels before the act of fratricide.

Joel has a clear-eyed manner of addressing the hypocrisy of the human condition, never flinching from direct conflict or hiding behind facile answers: "You have to find the courage to explore the darkness in your heart." Speaking succinctly, Joel peels away the layers of his persona, from frightened child terrorized by an out-of-control parent to a man who accepts the responsibility for putting an end to his brother's suffering.
For his part, Ellis listens carefully, remaining objective in the face of a dialog that questions the most basic belief systems, the existence or non-existence of God, man's personal responsibility in the greater scheme of things and nature vs. nurture. Joel becomes an ever more sympathetic character, a product of an environment that has shaped his future, Ellis his only link to understanding.

Cutting into the heart of the novel, the author delivers a staggering revelation, altering perceptions in a brilliantly crafted psychological thriller. The lines between truth and fiction are so smoothly blended, it is impossible to distinguish one from another. An incisive mind tunneling deeply into the dynamics of his skillfully constructed characters, this author proves once more to be a writer of substance, a thrilling manipulator of the human psyche. Luan Gaines/ 2007.

5.0 out of 5 stars Riveting, February 24, 2008

By	Gregory Kennedy (Fayetteville, AR USA) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

This book keeps you on edge from start to finish. It's a masterful story that even manages to hook readers into empathizing with the murderer. Joel's character is a great mystery we spend the whole book trying to figure out - and through a series of interesting twists we are led to an excellent ending, where we may get a chance to finally discover what's REALLY going on.

It's a short read, too. You'll get through it in a handful of sessions. Of course, once you get to the climax, you'll want to read it through again - plan accordingly!

One note: Hollon takes a bit of a risk here. Since most of the book is a conversation between two people, the author uses two slightly different fonts to differentiate between who is talking. While it frees the text from a constant stream of "N said" phrases, this can be distracting at first. Readers should quickly adapt to it, though.