Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disappointing, April 22, 2007
The book has too many errors and is poorly edited. Some of the errors are minor. For example, pg 26 step 5 says to quit the Interface Builder and save when prompted. The very next step says to select the button control and click Show Inspector... hmm, can't do that if the Interface Builder is closed. There are several instances of these kind of errors sprinkled throughout, and I'm only on pg 57 (of 363.)
Which brings me to my next problem. The second project is creating the Fortune Teller app. I've stopped at pg 57 because I can't get the app to run. The code is typed in exactly as in the book and it gives me an error when I build and run it. I'm running OS X 10.4, same as the author. No problem I thought, I'll just go to the web site and see if there are any corrections. Appendix A is called "What's on the companion web site?" and describes the code examples in the book. That's great, but they neglected to print the url to get to the site. I searched for 10 mins looking for it and found it in small print on the back of the book [...].
Now for the inexcusable part. I found the web page for this book with the download link to the code samples. The link shows as "33031_AppleScript_Source.ZIP". However, the link is really pointing to "33031_AppleScript_Source.exe". An executable? Well, not really because when I downloaded it, Get Info shows it as a document. I can't even open this document. I tried changing the extension to .zip but that didn't work. I also tried .gz and some other popular compression extensions but nothing works.
It's a shame. This book has the potential to be a great introduction to Applescripting and building apps that interact and leverage the power of other apps on your system. As it stands, I think absolute beginners, the target audience for this book, would quickly become frustrated and give up.
|
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Okay, where's the fireplace?, April 26, 2007
This book is a wonderful idea, but unfortunately, it's a total disaster. Here's why:
1) The book is poorly edited and a vast majority of the examples provided in it simply don't work.
2) The book claims that there's a companion website, but they don't tell you where it is.
3) After searching the web, I finally found on the company's website an MS Windows-only executable file, which contains the book's examples. Unfortunately, Mac users cannot open "Microsoft" programs, making the example files worthless.
As I said, this book is a good idea, but they did a terrible job producing it. This is definitely a DON'T BUY ITEM...
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
What happened to the "Studio" part?, July 2, 2008
Someone needs to write a book on Applescript Studio. This sure isn't it. 95% of it is on Applescript ONLY. This was supposed to on Applescript Studio, remember? I suspect the Studio part was left out because the author doesn't really know it very well. What few items look at Applescript Studio, and they are very few, are screen shots of menus, etc. This book was a big disappointment! I would buy a real Applescript Studio book in a heartbeat. Hopefully there is someone capable and willing to write it.
Very, very, poor.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|