Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
3 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Useful study of scaremongering, November 17, 2005
"It's all a matter of opinion." How often have we heard this when we venture to suggest, say, that astrology is tosh? But are all opinions equally valid? Aren't some based on stronger evidence than others?
Evidence is different from possibility. For example, the scaremongers at the New Scientist, the Independent, etc tell us that the AH5N1 avian flu virus could mutate into a virus transmissible to humans. Yes, it could. But how likely is it to do so?
The lead editorial in the British Medical Journal of 29 October 2005 said, "The lack of sustained human-to-human transmission suggests that this AH5N1 avian virus does not currently have the capacity to cause a human pandemic. ... the appearance of a modified avian virus capable of triggering a human pandemic is unlikely: there have been more than 3300 flu outbreaks in birds with 150 million killed and only 118 human cases, and the disease in birds is proving containable with good surveillance and prompt action."
Focusing on mythical scares distracts us from real problems. This book cites the example of the scare about DDT, which led to its banning in the late 1960s. As a result, malaria, which the use of DDT had almost eliminated, kills, worldwide, three million people, mostly children, every year.
This very useful book studies scare stories promoted in Britain about all sorts of things that, we're told, damage our health - British beef, salt, sugar, tap water, alcohol, non-organic food, the MMR vaccine, GM foods and sunshine. Given all these mortal scares, how come that generally we are living longer and healthier lives?
Are our rulers promoting paranoia, trying to scare us into feeling too weak and helpless to resist them? Is the destruction of Britain's industry leading to hostility to science itself? To paraphrase President Franklin D. Roosevelt, perhaps the only epidemic we have to fear is fear itself.
|
|
|
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Junk Science at its worst, January 30, 2007
The number of logic fallacies, unquantified opinions and illogical rants is shocking for a book that is about other myths.
Example, some of the most egregious examples:
Page 37: The Myth: "Junk food causes ill health". The Fact: "There is no such thing as food that is bad and food that is good for you." Really, all food is equally good for you?
Page 48: The Myth: "Non-Organic foods are covered in harmful pesticides". The Fact: "One of the pesticides deemed safe by organic produces carriers a warning that it is harmful to fish."
A proper book would look to determine if the myth is true or not (and that is what I was hoping for.) But instead, the fact does not refute the myth, doesn't provide if organic foods are good or bad, and is irrelevant to the discussion.
Time and time again, the authors avoid meaningful debate and rather simply rely on name calling and off the cuff opinions.
|
|
|
3 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Possibility of Pandemic Requires Preparation, not Dismissal, March 26, 2006
Patricia F. Stephens, M.ASCP #81:
Mr. Wm. Podmore's negative remarks for the necessity for world security from H5N1 influenza virus ignore factual information from the World Health Organization and other reliable sources concerning the history of the world's average of three pandemic's every one hundred years, and also fails to point out that we have had only two pandemics thus far and are now at the end of the current one hundred years. One can and should learn from historical facts!
He also fails to mention that the present H5N1 infections require concurrent "ordinary" flu infection at the same time as H5N1 in the human incubator in order to explode and cause the third pandemic of this century. We were lucky this year. If the infected wild bird migration into Alaska and then into the lower states next fall brings H5N1 together with the usual plain flu, the shoe may have dropped.
While there are many immune system builders on line and in health food stores which could help prevent infection (particularly mushroom products, says Dr. Nan Fuchs) it is certainly a fact that pharmaceutical companies are promoting useless and harmful drugs while silently clapping their hands at the scare tactics bringing in obscene profits.
Neither side of the fence can be absolutely certain about coming events, but to suggest it's unnecessary to prepare for this clear possibility is worse than careless--it is inane.
|
|
|
|
