|
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good, but not great. OVERPRICED., February 27, 2000
This book is not as good as I had hoped. I think it suffers in the following areas:1) It's got a serious Eastern Europe/former Soviet Bloc slant. This could provide a refreshing point of view, but it's hard to cover this subject well while practically ignoring such widely-used arms as the Browning M2. 2) It actually doesn't spend much time on any specific weapons, treating the subject in more of a theoretical manner. Connected with this, most of the drawings (there are no photos) are semi-schematic rather than cut-away style views of actual weapons. Some of them are a little hard to interpret, too. 3) A little bit was lost in the translation. The authors do not always use what I believe to be the standard U.S. terminology. They use "weapon casing" for "receiver" and a couple other odd ones. 4) This book is fairly packed full of complicated-looking mathematical formulas. I suppose such things are essential to modern scientific small arms design, but to me they make boring reading. I also doubt that John Browning or "Carbine" Williams ever took such an egg-headed approach to things. 5) Speaking of "Carbine" Williams, I don't see anything in this book about floating chambers. Also nothing about the principles and advantages of the high/low pressure system for small arms use. I think there's a lot of odds and ends missing from here that would be important for a well rounded understanding of the small arms field. These things said, I guess if I didn't have this book now I would still want to get it. EDIT: It's almost two years now since I purchased this book, and I see the price has risen dramatically from the already-high 60 bucks or so I paid for it. In my judgement, it is simply no way worth the current price unless you are so hardcore that you simply must have every word written on this subject. I would recommend getting the book, "U.S. Army Weapons Command Technical Notes -- Small Arms Design" published by Armalite. It sells for about [...], and covers quite similar material.
|