|
|
27 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Lavish, but disappointing, March 4, 2005
One thing; if you already own George Perry's Complete Phantom of the Opera, you don't need this book! The first two sections of this Companion, which deal respectively with the former versions of Phantom (the original Gaston Leroux novel, the 1925 silent movie and its successors) and Andrew Lloyd Webber's musical (the idea, the writing, the casting and the ensuing success) are both very interesting, but are merely summarys of the same two sections in Perry's book. However, it is the part about the movie itself that is the most disappointing: while I expected comprehensive interviews with the cast and crew members, details about the shooting, etc, all we get is 2 pages for each of the followings: an interview with Andrew Lloyd Webber, one with Joel Schumacher, brief bios of the main leads, details about the music, production and set design and ONE page on the costume and make-up. I should speak of half-pages actually, because there are more pictures than text. And all of these are mainly details you'll have read already, the "music" stuff is written word-for word in the booklet of the new extended soundtrack CD, and finally, you get less information than if you go to the movie's website. Two redeemers, though: the pictures are truly wonderful, colorful and lavish, including many never-before-seen from the movie, and the book includes the whole screenplay, which gives away many interesting details and allows to understand the characters better. There are many stage indications and scenes that differ from the final movie version (most have been simply skipped), and reading it, I found myself thinking that it would have made the movie better if they had followed the original script. For the real phanatics only, or maybe the newcomers.
|