|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not as good as "Nikon Compendium" published by Hove, September 16, 1999
I'm an experienced photographer who uses many of the lenses in the book. I have different oppinions of their performance than Moose. For instance, Moose dislikes the performance of the 85/2 AI-s and I love it.On the other hand, lenses all vary greatly due to production tolerances, so no lens will always agree with what anyone says. Yes, the book has a lot of info and is one of the few books of it's kind. OK, it's probably the biggest book there is on current Nikkor lenses, so give it a few more stars if it's the only book you can find. Therefore it is very valuable. However the information is not entirely accurate. Watch out for incorrect matching of illustrations and captions. Moose is a great photographer; not a lens designer. Therefore his impressions relate to how well they relate to his wonderful work in the field, and not necessarily how well the lenses perform technically or even what all the various technical innovations mean or how they work inside the lens. I suggest referring to "The Nikon Compendium" (also only 1994 edition) for more correct info if you really are curious about "how sharp" any lens is. Also look at Nikon's own book, "Eyes of Nikon" from the early 1980's for the best look into their manual focus lenses of that era. We'll see how well corrected the new edition is. Thanks to Moose for taking the effort to write the book! This review (c) 1999 Ken Rockwell. All rights reserved
|