Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
20 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A great read, and a major piece of scholarship, December 15, 1999
This is really a terrific book for a lot of reasons -- best of all it's completely fun to read (you won't be able to put it down) plus it's so packed with rare and esoteric information that in about five minutes you'll have absorbed enough obscure factoids to impress anybody at the next Beatles convention, and even sound nearly as expert as author Kristofer Engelhardt himself, a true Beatles scholar and collector who has lovingly gathered the information here for the past seven years. That in itself is extraordinary: how many writers have spent seven years researching one book? And the author's ambitious scope is immediately obvious: it's amazing how active and involved the Beatles have been in other musicians' recording sessions from the most famous (Dylan, Beach Boys, Zappa) to the utterly obscure (Crowbar, Splinter, Timon, though most musicians here will be familiar) as well as to combinations of both (who were all those players in 'Elephant's Memory'? ). But what makes this book really so valuable is that Engelhardt has a professional historian's fanaticism for accuracy. Full disclosure: I've been lucky enough to know couple of the musicians discussed here (Dennis and Brian Wilson, guitar legend Jesse Ed Davis) and the facts Engelhardt entertainingly lays out in BEATLES UNDERCOVER are all rock-solid as far as I can tell. Tangential rant: it's not widely known but a lot of rock and roll "history" books are junk...woefully inaccurate and historically useless, with various tales, myths and canards repeated ad infinitum verbally and then immortalized in print by so-called professional writers who really don't know what they're talking about (Steve Gaines' book on the Beach Boys is a glaring example... ). Here you get the real thing -- as far as I can tell everything here is solid gold you can take to the bank, and no doubt BEATLES UNDERCOVER will be must-read basic source material for all future writers with a serious interest in the Beatles and the 60's-and-beyond pop music scene. Besides the Beatles' own stories there's a further interest served with Engelhardt's fascinating and erudite thumbnail overviews of the careers of all the non-Beatle artists discussed. If you didn't know that Count Basie was born in 1904, started on the drums and then studied piano with Fats Waller, it's all here, and if BEATLES UNDERCOVER does neglect to mention that Jesse Ed Davis claimed to have taught Duane Allman how to play the slide guitar -- a claim with substantial merit it turns out -- that's only because the Beatles never jammed with the Allman brothers ... because if they had, they'd be in this book!. A great read, and a major piece of scholarship that will be re-read for pleasure and consulted for serious study for a long time to come.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This book is Incredible, April 19, 1999
By A Customer
Beatles Undercover is mandatory reading for any fan of the fab four.It not only lists every conceivable session that The Beatles played on that was not a Beatles project -(UNDER "cover" - get it?), but it gives an in-depth bio on the people who played with John, Paul, George & Ringo. Doris Troy, David Peel, Denny Laine, Jo Jo Laine (who phoned me last night!), and many more.Alvin Lee's "Real Life Blues" featuring Jon Lord of Deep Purpleand George Harrison is just oneexample of the nuggets uncovered here. The bio information on thesongs and the artists is even morein-depth than ROCK ENCYCLOPEDIA byLillian Roxon, which set the standard way back in the sixties.And that is the highest praise I cangive this or any book
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Prepare to be amazed, December 29, 1998
By A Customer
Kristofer Engelhardt's book "Beatles Undercover" is a detailed and comprehensive look into The Beatles' session work for over 200 recording artists. The author interviewed a tremendous number of musicians who worked with The Beatles. Many of them recount their previously undocumented musical encounters with The Beatles. Years of exhausting and painstaking research obviously went into the making of this fascinating work. For fans of The Beatles who are jaded by the same old rehashed information this book will be a revelation. The wealth of beautiful b&w and color photos and reproductions of documents alone makes this a "must have" book. It belongs on the bookshelf of every self-respecting fan of The Beatles or fans of the dozens of other famous artists covered in the book. If that weren't enough this 550 page book also includes a bonus CD of previously unreleased recordings produced by John Lennon. What a treat and what a bargain at $26.00. If you thought there was nothing new under the sun about The Beatles, prepare to be amazed by "Beatles Undercover." Ernie Clark
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Tony Barrow
