Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Silence Flows Faster Backwards..., August 18, 2002
Whether you think it is deep or merely whimsical, it is awfully difficult to dislike a film which starts with Death's chauffeur calling the cops because the poets are brawling at the local cafe. Jean Cocteau's Orphee (Orpheus) is possibly the most uncharacterizable film ever: neither high art nor low, and neither a recasting of the classical Orphic myth nor a refutation of the original. If anything, Orphee is in fact all of these things simultaneously, and therein lies its art. In the original Greek myth, Orphee loses his wife and is told that he may go to the underworld and retrieve her if he takes her by the hand and never looks back. He fails at this and she is gone to him and he returns to the world of the living without her. In an affiliated legend, Orphee dies a bloody death years later but is consequently reunited with his wife Eurydice who has been waiting for him. The original myth suggests a belief in a romantic love that endures past death, but one that specifically rewards monogamous faithfullness. But with stipulations:the reward is in the next world, with no promises regarding thisworldly happiness. Moreover, the Greeks didn't allow for what happens to the bonds formed with subsequent spouses of widowed people. This clearly troubled Cocteau, as does his Catholic "till death do us part", wherein people are expected to never divorce or seek new lovers, and to not have mates in the afterlife. Cocteau's version is similarly unpromising with respect to thiswordly happiness, but since Heurtibise(Death's chauffeur) and Euridice secretly wish to be together, as do the "Princess"(i.e., Death) and Orphee, maybe in their failure they get what they want. So Cocteau holds out hope in his retelling, adapting the myth to suit his purposes while he simultaneously mocks the importance of myth-making. (At one point Orphee is asked by one of the underworld judges if he is a writer. He replies that he is a poet, adding that "a poet is a writer who writes but isn't a writer.) With Heurtebise's help(and trick photography), Orphee goes back to the underworld to retrieve his wife. When he arrives he is made to testify in some sort of trial. He thinks he is on trial at first, but it is the princess, Death who is on trial, and it is through the process of the trial that he realizes that she loves him too. Later, he says to Death- Orphee:"Who gives the orders?" Death:"They come to us, as if in a dream...or like the beating of jungle drums." Orphee:"I will go to him who gives the orders." Death:"Some think he imagines us. Others that he sleeps, and we are his dreams..." This exchange is the closest that Cocteau comes to offering a set of religious beliefs anywhere in Orphee. (Perhaps notably, one of the nonsense verses that come across the car radio earlier tells Orphee that the dreamer must listen to his dreams.) Cocteau is more concerned with mood than with plot per se, and I suppose this may trouble some viewers. But for me, the dream-like, atmospheric quality of this film is more than suitable compensation. The car radio is right...
|
|
|
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Great movie, awful print. Avoid! Get the more expensive one., February 11, 2000
By A Customer
I have seen the 'cheap' version of this movie on VHS and it is terrible. A beautiful, mesmerizing film butchered by terrible sound, a faded print, and subtitles that go off the screen. The people responsible for this should be ashamed. This edition is truly a waste of money.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Masterpiece by a Master, April 3, 2000
No one in film moved toward a transformation of the mythic impulse for modernity more profoundly than Jean Cocteau, and this is a perfect example of that art in practice. The film's influence, along with the rest of Cocteau's work ranges far and wide. One can see it in the work of David Lynch, in last year's Sixth Sense, etc. This is a film about a poet, but it's much more, it's poetry itself.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|