Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
98 of 103 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Help, indeed! Spare us this lame marketing ploy., July 27, 2000
With the "A Hard Day's Night" DVD currently out of print, Bealtes fans have had to make due with the DVDs presented in this dubious "Collector's Set." All are available separately, so save you dollars! As much as I love the group, I see little reason to own "Magical Mystery Tour" on DVD. The "documentary" of the making of AHDN isn't bad, but my VHS copy will suffice. Which leaves "Help!" and "...Their First US Visit." Personally, I'm holding out for the deluxe editions of the feature films. Hello Criterion? You did a nice laser disc of AHDN, where's the DVD? And how about a proper "making of" documentary, with more Lester and less Phil Collins? "Help!" is a great film, but would also benefit from similar additional first-hand recollections. Which leaves "The Beatles: Their First US Visit." Of this foursome (pending the arrival of an expanded "Help!" DVD), this is the only true must-have disc: a cinema verite look at Beatlemania from the boys' perspectives (...a car, a room, a car, a room...), beautifully observed by the Maysles brothers in 1964. The Ed Sullivan show bits are wonderful, but my favorite moment is John noodling on the melodica, playing what you'll recognize as the intro to "Strawberry Fields Forever." This documentary is a rare, amazing glimpse into a world we'll never see again. I'm saving my money for the Anthology DVDs slated for late 2000/early 2001.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
67 of 70 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
I had no idea, September 14, 2000
I had no idea I was so lucky to have a DVD copy of Hard Day's Night. This is just another repackaging of stuff already released. Most Beatle fans know too much about that.As for the individual titles, Help is an excellent movie. The big buget sequel to A Hard Day's Night. Magical Mystery Tour is really, really sad. When it was released origially for TV in Britian it was supposed to air twice but after poor ratings was not rerun. It was only run on American TV once in black and white. The one good thing about Magical Mystery Tour is that it was digitally restored from the original film stock and the soundtrack was remastered in digital stereo. I had a copy of Magical Mystery Tour released in the 80's by Media Home Entertainment, and it was pretty much bootleg quality. The First U.S. Visit is an excellent documentary. It begins with the Beatles landing at JFK airport for their fist U.S. Tour. Then they are off for their first appearance on the Ed Sullivan show. It has footage from their first live concert in America in Washington D.C. It then follows them on the historic train ride to Miami for their second appearance on the Ed Sullivan Show. One of the best sequences is on the train when John and Paul are very tired of mugging for the cameras but George is going crazy. Little did they know at the time that they would be under the microscope from then on!! The making of Hard Day's Night is just ok. Like someone else said, "less Phil Collins, more info..." I need to see Let It Be on DVD and the making of Let It Be. Let It be is over two weeks of informal jamming boiled down to about an hour and a half. Bottom line is buy this release if you don't have any of the titles in it. It makes a fair starter collection of Beatle DVDs.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
32 of 33 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Another gripe; and where is 'Compleat Beatles?', August 7, 2000
Add mine to the list of Beatlemaniacs underwhlemed by the selections in this set. (Consider my rating an average of five stars for the films and one star for this box itself.)Like pbfey, despite my fanaticism, I see no need to own 'MMT' on disc until somebody cleans up the video further and makes a "What the heck were they thinking?" making-of featurette to go with it. (Cue Ringo: "Yeah, it sooked, but Brian was gone, and we were all so wasted...") I already have 'AHDN' on DVD (thanks to eBay), as well as 'Help!' And when 'AHDN' is finally back in print, folding in the 'You Can't Do That!' making-of would be the egalitarian thing to do. I hope you're right about the 'Anthology' coming to DVD by early '01, pbfey, but you know what I'm really hankering for? The modest 1982 MGM documentary 'The Compleat Beatles.' This PBS pledge-drive staple is, at two hours, the tightest, most all-around entertaining Fabs documentary ever -- a much easier watch than the essential but bloated 'Anthology.' (Many a rainy day at home has been rejuvenated by my umpteenth watching of 'Compleat.') It's now completely out of print, even on VHS, so I must continue to rely on my mossy tape copy. Crazy as this sounds, I'd take a DVD of that little flick over almost anything else Beatles-related at this point. But I suspect it's not an MGM or an MPI priority, so I'm not holding my breath.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|