Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
18 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A clear and comprehensive explanation of Buddhist meditation, October 8, 1999
A systematic introduction to the development of insight through meditation. It covers ethical foundations, all aspects of concentration, including the jhanas and the four foundations of mindfulness (contemplation of body, feelings, states of mind and mind objects)-and the stages of realization of wisdom. Included is the role of the teacher, as well as the subjects of meditation and their appropriateness to different practicioners. A scholarly, clear and comprehensive commentary.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Scholarly and technical textbook on Theravada Buddhist meditation theory, January 9, 2009
This book is unique in several aspects. First, it is written by a Theravadian monk originally from Sri Lanka, with a Ph.D. in philosophy from the American University in Washington D.C. Second, it is a book on the theory of samatha and vipassana meditation (i.e., serenity and insight meditation) as opposed to a book on meditation techniques that focuses on the different objects of meditation. (Only some of the traditional objects of meditation are mentioned and many are not mentioned at all.) Finally, the book is very technical and full of Pali nomenclature. It is published in India and physically is of better quality than the average Indian paperback, but not as good as the average American paperback.
While the English and editing is excellent, it is still a very difficult book to understand as the book is not watered down and covers advanced meditation theory. This book is meant either for academics or those who want a very in-depth theoretical account of how to develop samatha (one pointed concentration or calm abiding) and insight (vipassana) according the Pali canon. It requires serious study to understand. It thoroughly covers the theoretical aspects of the four jhanas and all the mental factors that must be present and the mental factors that hinder the attainment of the first four jhanas. I know of no other book that is comparable. It is an essential text for anyone serious about developing a stable, concentrated and one pointed mind. (Note, Pali: jhana = Sanskrit: dhyana. Note, the first a should be long.)
As near as I can tell this is Henepola Gunaratana's first book. His subsequent books are way less technical and theoretical and are much easier to understand. This book is essentially his 1980 doctoral dissertation from the American University under Dr. David Rodier titled:<<A Critical Analysis of the Jhanas in Theravada Buddhist Meditation>>. This dissertation is available online. Just Google the above title.
Finally, another very useful and complimentary text is <<Samatha Meditation>> by Gen Lamrimpa, translated by Alan Wallace and edited by Hart Sprager. It is a well edited compilation of the oral teachings Gen Lamrimpa gave during the first two weeks of a one year Samatha retreat in the U.S. to a group of Western meditators in 1988. These teachings were based <<The Great Exposition of the Stages of the Path of Awakening>> by Tsong-kha-pa, <<The Stages of the Listeners>> by Asanga, <<The Essence of the Center>> by Santaraksita and <<The States of Meditation>> and <<Compendium of Practices>> by Kamalasila. The terminology and stages are significantly different from the Theravada system. For example, <<Samatha Meditation>> describes a nine stage system versus the Theravada four stage system, but both take one to the same destination. Highly recommended.
|
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Excellent explanation of the Buddhist path, June 29, 2009
This book is a good treatment of the methodology of the path of meditation as it pertains to pursuing liberation in the Buddhist spiritual discipline, both that of the meditation absorptions of the jhanas, and of "dry" insight meditation, the latter not necessarily being dependent upon the former.. It is a very orthodox work, not explaining the path in everyday layman's terms as the author's other mindfulness book, just the essential structure of the gradual training and the mechanics of meditation and the different elements of practice that factor into the process along the way.
Very good, Orthodox, even scholarly, and simple. It explains the whole path; the gradual training, the jhanas, the stages of purification and the progress of insight. Major points of interest and answers to common questions as explanations of the path and its constituents are made.
I want to stress again that this work is a much more technical (though still quite accessible) and scholarly work than the author's bestselling "Mindfulness in Plain English" and "Eight Mindful Steps to Happiness". It has the feel of a scripture, commentary, or other orthodox-flavored work on Theravada Buddhism.
All in all, a helpful treatment on stages of the path to enlightenment and every step and factor along the way. Good to study to develop an understanding of the entire path before you begin. Very much recommended.
Portions of this book are available for free viewing on Google Books. Just search for the title of this book and you will see the title come up in the first few matches.
|
|
|
|