Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
My Review of the book, August 9, 2005
Likes:
- The book has been written in a very beautifully organized manner.
-great infomation on the IAF fighters that took part in the 1965 war and their comparision with the PAF fighters of the same era. detailed information about Sqdn deployment, their strength and their Sqdn and station commanders.
-detailed information with personal accounts from pilots that took part in the missions.loved reading about A T Cooke's Sabre kill, Sargodha Raids by Mysteres, W/C Wilson's Badin Raid - details such such as weapons load on each of the Canberra has been mentioned and its wonderful and many more such detailed missions.
- day by day chronology of missions and their results.
- good quality pictures and gun cam pics.the binding of the book is good too..
-the last page appendices of IAF Kills, Losses and Gallantry Award Winner.
- what i appreciate the most about the authors is their transparency.they have mentioned their sources for their findings and given credit to the persons who deserve it.
what i would have liked to seen:
- while the size of the pictures are small(and i wish that they were big), i think they blend nicely with the font size of the text.larger pics,i think, would have looked a bit odd.
- the maps of eastern front and western front(with airbases,cities and targets) should have been there along withe the chapters
-i would love to have seen a mention of the Myth regarding M M Alam's Kills - just to set the records straight.
|
|
|
6 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
This is a good book, August 11, 2005
This is a super book and a landmark in the annals of the "Historical record challenged" Indian nation.
The best part about the book is that it makes easy reading. The descriptions of the scenes and battles took me right back to my childhood where I would have my heart racing reading the adventures of Biggles, a fictional World War I fighter pilot. And the book has pictures to boot - real action photos in some cases placed in contextually relevant areas.
The similarity is not coincidental. Indian pilots in 1965 may have been flying jets - but everything else was exactly like World War I. Almost no radar cover, equipment malfuntion leading to aborted missions, absent or poor communication equipment, guns jamming, bombs failing to explode or exploding too soon, dizzying dogfights with the air thick with fighters and ack ack, intrigue, sabotage, death and drama. The men literally flew "on a wing and a prayer" and still did a great job and learned lessons that were later put to good use.
The concluding chapters have an eminently readable, objective and honest assessment in a very academic and very Indian tradition of "Truth will triumph". Other positive points include reference placed conveniently at the end of each chapter rather than a whole confusing chapter of refs at the end.
I have a couple of complaints. There are about 5 or 6 typos in the entire book - which is a miniscule number - but will need attention. There are references to "attrition rate" as a percentage with no difinition of how it was arrived at or applied.
Buy this book folks. We need to make sure the authors have enough funds to work on the history of the 1971 air war.
|
|
|
5 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Needs refinement, August 11, 2005
The most balanced and objective account of the 1965 Air War available.
Pluses :
- Very well written.
- Very detailed encounters with capabilties of related a/c being taken into consideration.
- Debunking of many fallacious PAF claims including an accurate picture of actual IAF orbat
- Balanced perspective all the way.
- Credit where credit is due, always. The 8 pass-charlie section is very good.
- Extensive Tables including table of Canberra ops. This could have possibly been extended to other a/c and events. A timeline summary of events perhaps?
- Fricker centric. Debunks many claims but also fills gaps.
- Extensive list of interviewees and references. Gives the complete picture of events from both sides. The complete picture for the first time, has been put on paper.
- Day by Day narrative and post-war encounters.
- Eventual and current status of IAF and PAF participants in the war.
Minuses :
- Not relatively photo intensive, smallsize photos only
- No maps
- Detailed orbat of PAF and analysis missing.
- Too much emphasis on individual a/c of IAF orbat over overall capabilties which would need an individual analysis. Not too much detail of technical warmaking or (Fighter and ground based) Sensor capabilties of both sides.
- Expected more wreckage photos. Expected tons actually and perhaps a consolidated gallery.
- Not too much attention to the myth of MM Alam. A comparison with AT Cooke could have been done here.
-More details on Naval Aviation activities expected.
For maximum enjoyment, you should'nt have discovered the Bharat Rakshak 1965 war section. If you have'nt spent too much time there, then this book is a 100% absolute must buy, even if you are'nt aware of the existance of India (and Pakistan) or are'nt into this field. However, if you are somewhat familiar with the events of the airwar, it would translate into a benefit.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Yefim Gordon
by Jared A. Zichek
