|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Finally Free Of The Fruit Cellar, July 27, 2002
First of all, for all of those who have whinned about preferring an "original" soundtrack recording -- forget about it! Was never made; never will be.The 1975 Unicorn-Kanchana recording, conducted by Bernard Herrmann, (the 1989 cd is a VERY difficult import to acquire) has been the definitive version of the entire soundtrack -- until this 1997 recording. Much as I respect many of Danny Elfman's original scores - particularly Dolores Claiborne, Black Beauty, Mars Attacks and even the amusing MIB II prelude - his treatment of Herrmann's masterpiece is only a nice try. With all that out of the way, and after considerable time spent comparing the recording Herrmann finally had the opportunity to make shortly before he died, (which I have been listening to regularly for over 25 years) with McNeely's version which I have been avoiding for a few years, my advice: This is now the definitive version and will likely remain so for decades. Barring a much needed remastering of the Naional Philharmonic-Herrmann cd, you will NEVER hear this score, which is simply one of the finest musical compositions of the 20th century, the way it must be heard. Depth, clarity and separation between the various strings - particularly the celli and basses - is exceptional. Like listening to the music for the first time! The prelude has most - though not quite enough - of its frenzy back. The two missing cues are very interesting and most welcome. There is a nice inversion at the start of The Window which makes it more interesting. Every track is engineered impeccably, with a nice sustain and ring-off to the strings just the way it ought to be. Originally I found certain cues, like The City, The Curtain, and even The Water uninspired, too measured and lacking spirit. Likewise, I still find Herrmann's conducting usually has more of the flow and flavor of the music's essence which McNeely sometimes seems to lose track of. However, the overall dedication to craft and total respect for the quality of this score is perfectly obvious. I regret having waited so long to purchase this recording. Lastly: The liner notes, though decent, really deserved to be more detailed and technical. You can hear maestro Herrmann doing such simple yet sublimely subtle things with his score now, and it would have been so helpful for us non-musicians if there had come included a bit more explanation as to what compositional elements they are. And why not have a companion video recording of this recording session? Now THAT would finally free Herrmann's masterpiece even more from its neglected past!
|