Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
32 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A beautiful collection of classic songs from ARS, May 28, 1999
Disregard the negative review below, which is actually about a completely different CD. This ARS anthology covers their years on the Polydor label, years that produced 8 albums with a dazzling collection of songs in many different styles, all stamped with the unique ARS recorded sound. All of the essentials are here ... the radio hits of 1977-1979, plus important album tracks that really defined ARS. "Angel," from 1974, features Barry Bailey's passionate guitar solo against a dramatic string arrangement; "Dog Days," the title song of their 1975 album, is a gorgeous ballad, led by Ronnie Hammond's vocal and another fine string arrangement; "Neon Nites" and "Georgia Rhythm", from 1977's "A Rock and Roll Alternative," display ARS' versatility in very different styles. ARS was recorded very differently than other Southern bands of their time. Buddy Buie's production emphasized a smoothly layered sound, and every ARS recording emphasized the song before the performance. Thus, Bailey's fire and brimstone guitar on "Angel" is replaced on "Neon Nites" with some tasty jazz riffing; "So Into You," with its languid rhythms, demands no pyrotechnics, so instead it gets a smoothly integrated piano/guitar sound which gives Hammond the solid groove on which to lay a great vocal track. With ARS, everything served the song ... and what a fabulous collection of songs! 1979's "Do It or Die" anticipated the Unplugged phenomenon by several years; "Silver Eagle," with its road-weary lyric and sweet steel guitar fits in very nicely with the New Country sound; and "Indigo Passion" is a simply magnificent ballad. Listen to Hammond's aching vocal, backed by Dean Daughtry's supple keyboards and Robert Nix's muffled drums. ARS' ability with ballads contrasted sharply with the widespread presumption that Southern bands knew only how to boogie. That may have been true of some Southern bands, but not ARS. This CD is a deeply satisfying experience. All the hits are here, but it's the album tracks that really fill in the picture, of a supremely gifted group of songwriters and studio craftsmen, working together to create music they believed in, music which has stood the test of time.
|
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Insufficient. ARS deserves a 2 Disc "Anthology", February 5, 2006
This CD offers a mere smattering of what the Atlanta Rythmn Section was all about. It does give you what the casual listener might have heard on the radio at the bands peak of popularity, which to be fair was short lived. But radio play popularity doesn't matter when it comes to bands like this. ARS, like many 70s bands, and particularly southern rock types, weren't popular because of their radio hits. Their appeal to those who first heard their crossover hits on the radio was the cherry on the sundae. What made them great were solid, beginning to end CDs like their first 2 breakthroughs- "A Rock and Roll Alternative," and "Champagne Jam," both of which are inadequately represented here, albeit not unfairly represented. After all, this is a "Greatest Hits" collection. But if you want to get a truer, more representive measure of what made this band great and got them radio play in the first place, I say skip this CD and buy the 2 aforementioned CDs, which would have necessities like, "Hitchhikers Hero, Outside Women Blues, Everybody Gotta Go Sometime, Don't Miss the Message, Evil Eve," and "Large Time," just to name a mere few. To get to this CD, it does take the most popular tracks from those CDs, but the songs selected from those and subsequent CDs to follow are disproportionate. Add to that there are a few songs on this CD that don't even belong there, but are there merely because of an apparent need to put something on the CD from the entire span of the bands existence, even though their latter CDs were a shadow of their best two. If memory serves, the band in its latter stages was also a mere shadow of their best, early period as well. But to be fair, of all the ARS "hits" collections this one is probably more complete than the others, which isn't saying much. This group deserves a 2 disc anthology. Lesser bands have that much. I'm not going to say they're deserved of a box set. As much as I loved this band, the breadth of their musical lifespan isn't worthy of that much. But if lesser bands- take your pick: the hair bands of the 80s, the few hit wonders of the 60s and 70s, the bands who got one or two of their songs made popular in dance clubs- are worthy of a minimal of a 2 disc anthology, surely The Atlanta Rythmn Section can get that much.
|
|
|
15 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great compilation of original versions of ARS classics, February 17, 2002
By A Customer
WARNING: MOST OF THE REVIEWS THAT SAY THESE ARE NOT THE ORIGINAL SONGS ARE ACTUALLY REFERRING TO ANOTHER ARS ALBUM!
They have many best-of CDs, so be careful. This one is excellent.With that said, this is the THE cd to own if you are going to only own one ARS CD. Unfortunately, only about 1/2 of their catalogue has ever been released on CD and much of it is hard to find (their classic "Are You Ready?" live album has never been released on CD). These are the original versions of these classics and the sound has not been re-produced as has been the case with subsequent ARS greatest hits compilations. I could argue with a few tunes that were included and few that were left off (two of their later hits "Alien" and "Homesick" were recorded for a later record company and are not included in this package), but overall this is great music from an underappreciated band. A slight tweeking of the track list and this CD would have been 5 stars. What a great band, voice and sound.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
~ Firefall
~ Ambrosia
~ Pure Prairie League
~ Classics Four
by Atlanta Rhythm Section 
