Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Honest And Revealing Album From A Master Songwriter, January 14, 2000
It was a surprise to me how revealing Paul Simon was in this album. Always a private man, Paul chose to let the listener see the progression of his relationship with Actress Carrie Fisher, from meeting, falling in love, marriage, the strains, the sad breakup, and divorce. The title track is achingly honest: "Love like lightning, shaking 'till it moans" and "Why won't you love me for who I am, what I am?--That's not the way the world works, baby."--one can just about hear his pain. The album's not the best in terms of production--the sound is not the best--but with other songs "Rene and Georgette Magritte With Their Dog, After The War" and "The Late Great Johnny Ace" (about Johnny Ace, JFK, and John Lennon) it is very well crafted in terms of imagery--Paul is a poet, not just a songwriter, who is capable of putting emotion in the simplest turn of a phrase. "Train In The Distance" is simple, but wide open: "From time to time, he tipped his heart/But each time she withdrew/Everbody loves the sound of a train in the distance/Everybody thinks it's true." No other album Paul has recorded since has been so straight-out revealing. Measured against his other previous albums--Grammy winner "Still Crazy after These Years" and his self-titled debut solo album "Paul Simon"--"Heart And Bones" was considered a commerical flop by music biz standards. Don't let that stop you. Borrow this from a friend. If you happen to find this CD in the bargain bin of your local music store, buy it!
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Paul Simon's best album?, July 29, 2002
This album was a commercial letdown, and is not normally mentioned early on when people think of Paul Simon. That said, it's an overlooked masterpiece, and just might be his best album. In addition to some great and very inventive music (Paul being caught here between the melancholy electric piano-led ballads of Still Crazy After All These Years and the musically ground-breaking Graceland), this is the album where Simon's enigmatic lyricism really came to the forefront (who else would write a song about allergies?.) One can tell merely from looking at the song titles that Paul was attempting something rather off-beat here - and he succeeds. The lyrics are not abstract, however: they're more of, as the editorial review says so well "dead beat surrealism." Some of the songs (the aforementioned Allergies, which features some awesome guitar work from Al Di Meola; the very strange When Numbers Get Serious; and the semi-hilarous but borderline facetious Cars Are Cars) are very lyrically strange, and one may well question their meaning - or intention. It's always good to hear such clever and well-crafted lyrics, however - regardles of their intent or meaning. That said, some of the other songs (such as the title track, Train In The Distance, and others) show Simon laid emotionally bare, and are great songs that touch the heart, as well as the mind and the soul. Rene and Georgette Margritte With Their Dog After The War and The Late Great Johnny Ace (which features an excellent musical coda from the great Philip Glass) are flat-out masterpieces. Hearts and Bones is an emotional, complex, and challenging album from Paul Simon that is not an easy listen. Like most great albums, it takes some time to get used to and some time to get into. The album, though, is well worth your time and effort. It is Paul Simon's masterpiece.
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An under-appreciated masterpiece, December 15, 2000
It's been said many times that Hearts and Bones gets lost in the shuffle of Paul Simon's recordings. I couldn't agree more. This is an album of beauty and wit and longing and love. For my money there may not be two more powerful songs of love, and love lost, than Hearts and Bones and Train in the Distance. I still get shivers when I hear Simon sing "You take two bodies and twirl them into one...their hearts and their bones, oh and they won't come undone." How stunning, and how beautiful. And then "Everybody loves the sound of a train in the distance, everybody thinks its true." I've heard that train in the distance and thought it was true, so the song has particular meaning for me.Both versions of Think Too Much are excellent. And of course, Johnny Ace. Still brings tears to my eyes. If you don't have this album, buy it...you will not regret it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Interact With Your Music: Discover, listen to, and buy new music, all from the pages of SPIN's digital edition, free to Amazon customers.
by Paul Simon 
