|
15 of 16 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
A great rock band gets an awfully lacking compilation, October 18, 2003
Starship's Greatest Hits (1991). The first official greatest hits compilation for Starship ranging from 1979-1991.Technically, the band Starship has actually existed since the late 60s, though they were a completely different band back then. From the late 60s to the mid 70s, they were known as Jefferson Airplane. From the mid 70s to the early 80s, they were Jefferson Starship. From 85 and onward, they were just Starship. This compilation picks an odd point to start with. They cover the years in Jefferson Starship starting from 1979 and proceeding all the way to the very last Starship album. I'm going to assume that they covered the time that lead singer Mickey Thomas was in the band. While this compilation does contain a lot of great music, it's lacking in quality quite a bit. As you'll soon find out, this greatest hits package is anything but perfect. Read below to find out why: (1979-1984) Jefferson Starship Tracks Jane, Find Your Way Back, Stranger, No Way Out, and Laying It On The Line comments: These are all great classic tracks, but why not just do a double disc compilation with one disc focusing on Jefferson Starship and the other focussing on Starship the pop rock band? (1985) KNEE DEEP IN THE HOOPLA We Built This City, Sara comments: They managed to include both hits, but 'WE BUILT THIS CITY' IS THE RADIO EDIT VERSION WITHOUT THE DJ AND THE INTRO! WHY?? The original version was perfect, so why did they have to shorten the song on a disc that already has tons of leftover album space to begin with? Also, where are some of the album's masterpiece tracks such as 'Tomorrow Doesn't Matter Tonight' or 'Love Rusts'? (1987) NO PROTECTION Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now, It's Not Over 'Til It's Over comments: Likewise, both the hits are here, but it's missing many key token Starship tracks. WHERE ARE 'BEAT PATROL', 'GIRLS LIKE YOU', AND ESPECIALLY 'BABYLON' THE ALBUM'S MASTERPIECE TRACK?! Their exclusions brings this compilation's value way down. (1989) LOVE AMONG THE CANNIBALS It's Not Enough comments: This album REALLY got cheated off of great tracks. 'It's Not Enough' became a sleeper hit, but there were so many greater songs to be found on the album. I'm talking about the tracks 'The Burn', 'Trouble In Mind', 'I Didn't Mean To Stay All Night' and especially 'Wild Again'. (1990-1991) Bonus Tracks Don't Lose Any Sleep, Good Heart comments: If this lackluster compilation has any redeeming factors about it, it's that there are a couple of new unreleased tracks made right before Starship disbanded. 'Don't Lose Any Sleep' is fairly average, but 'Good Heart' is worthy of mention. Overall, this is a severely mediocre greatest hits package. It fails to even come close to filling up the disk's storage limit and the booklet is lacking in any useful information as well. Thankfully, there are a couple of alternatives to go with. If you like the earlier era consisting of Jefferson Starship's songs, then the only collection worth getting is the double disc best of compilation. It's more money, but it's better than shelling out cash for this sorry collection. If you like starship, then look for a single disc comp. called "The Best Of Starship" which contains some 20 tracks or so. The only catch is that it's rare to find it. Only buy the Greatest Hits compilation if you are on an extremely low budget and if you can find it used. RECOMMENDED TO AVOID.
|