Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Different Side of AFI, October 8, 2005
AFI's third effort, 1997's "Shut Your Mouth And Open Your Eyes", still remains my favorite piece of music from the band (besides the "All Hallows" EP) despite it's age and significant difference from the band now adays. If you're a first time listener to the cd, there's going to be a lot of noticable differences from the AFI on this disc, and the AFI on "Art Of Drowning" or "Sing The Sorrow". Despite the differences however, "Shut Your Mouth And Open Your Eyes" provides you with the complete listening experience, and will undoubtably leave you coming back for more every time.
I would say this cd is when AFI was transitioning from their punk stage to their hardcore stage. Not that this cd is "hardcore", but it's considerably heavier than anything the band had done prior (and actually considerably heavier than most of the material the band has done now adays, well maybe except "Black Sails in The Sunset"). The heaviness of the record is what really gives it the edge though. "Keeping Out of Direct Sunlight", the album opener is a foreshadowing of what is to come on the record, before quickly jumping into one of my all time favorite AFI songs "Three Reasons". Davey's vocals are very different on this record, more of an old-school hardcore shout, mixed with some melodic singing more reminiscant of later AFI. The screaming/shouting does wonders for the album though. Songs like "Let It Be Broke" and "Coin Return" wouldn't have been as outstanding as they are if they hadn't had this give/take relationship of screaming and singing. There's plenty of great ones to choose from on here including the fan favorite "Third Season", my personal favorite "Triple Zero" and a cover of Filth's "Today's Lesson". Start to finish it really provides a great listen, mainly because the album doesn't have any filler or lagging. Totaling out at 14 songs and 28 minutes, there's just the right amount of music to keep you satisfied, enough to make you want to come back, and the right amount to make sure you don't get bored. Musically the band is far inferior to anything they are now (at this time Jade Puget was not with the band), but the music is still just as memorable, despite not being all that technical. There's really not a thing on this album I can complain about.
I absolutely urge you to give this cd a listen, especially if you're an AFI fan. It is definitely the most listened to AFI cd in my collection, and provides me with the most overall satisfaction. If you are more familiar with their new material ("Art Of Drowning", "Sing The Sorrow", ect...) then this is a great way for you to take a trip into the band's past. It definitely has the most unique sound of any AFI record, mainly because they were in a transition state. That's probably why it's the only one that has this raw sound to it. While their previous two albums were more on the punk side, and starting with "Black Sails In The Sunset" they moved more into goth territory, "Shut Your Mouth And Open Your Eyes" remains the only album that truely warrants the tag of "hardcore-punk", making it a unique addition to your AFI collection. Pick it up today, and fully appreciate what this one has to offer.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
If you are a new fan, this will be useful., August 24, 2004
It is okay to like new AFI, there is nothing wrong with that. Every once in awhile I, myself, will pull out STS. BUT, if you listen to AFI you'd think you'd atleast appreciate this cd. It's wonderful that they are progressing, but this cd is awesome. It shows what they are capable of. This was definitely before Jade. You can tell, because the music and lyrics weren't influenced by him. Once they did Black Sails in the Sunset (not Wind), there was no hope that they'd ever do a cd like this again. This is a wonderful cd that should be listened to be everyone.
|
|
|
7 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Afi's Harshest and Least Polished Work; Rage, October 22, 2006
Let me let you in on a little secret; all AFI is good. That's right ALL. Another secret; AFI is my favorite band of all time. Why? I'll show you.
'We are the Ones with the radiating eyes. We are the Ones who have a fire inside. We are the Ones only we can recognize. We've been rejected...'
...and that's the opening for this album, which is AFI's third. It's their harshest, angriest, meanest effort to date, and I don't think they will ever go back to this.
The sound? Fast and aggressive. The lyrics? Fast and pissed off! At one point, Davey's voice audibly cracks with the sheer rage-driven emotion that can't be found on any other AFI. Black_Sails_In_The_Sunset comes close, but it's better in other ways.
'Do you understand what I'm trying to say? Have you ever felt? Ever felt this way? Tainted with rage that you can't drain away or it will cost you your life.'...
...and that's the essesnce of this album. Davey Havok's lyrics are always poetic, unlike any other punk rock band anywhere, but here they trade in some of the band's later elloquence for sheer rage, and the result is an excellent, if slightly unpolished, representation of what the band has to offer.
So, if you like hardcore punk-rock, this is your AFI album.
And as for you who say AFI is not hardcore enough for you, go listen to harder music. If Slayer's Reign_In_Blood don't do it for you, try Converge's You_Fail_Me, or some Pig_Destroyer. But don't down a good band because they're not your kind of music.
For people who can appreciate AFI, and not just hardcore music, see also AFI-Black_Sails_In_The_Sunset, and AFI-The_Art_Of_Drowning. You won't be dissapointed.
PS For people new to AFI, I recommend starting at the middle with The_Art_Of_Drowning.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
is AFI's 
