|
100 of 117 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
This is the SECOND best Figaro!, October 8, 1999
This is a wonderful recording of the opera, but EMI's set by Giulini is slightly better than this Solti (DECCA) set. Here is my comparisionConductor: Advantage: DECCA! Both did a great job with keeping the music "fast paced" when needed and the score light. I rate Solti higher based soley on what he did with the overture. Figaro: Advantage: EMI! I love Ramey, but Taddei has a much more commanding and comic presence. He is brilliant in the role, and is one of the greatest tenors of all time. Taddei's intrepretation of Figaro's Act I ending aria is worth the price alone. I have never heard the aria sung with such greatness. Susanna: Advantage: EMI! Anna Moffo has got to be the best Susanna on record. She is lovely. When I hear her sing Susanna, I imagine- "this must be the Susanna Mozart pictured while writting the opera." Count: Advantage: EMI! Wachter without a doubt holds the edge here. Countess: Advantage: EVEN! This is where the tie falls. The DECCA set is worth it alone for the beautiful and stunning performance Kanawa gives, and Schwartzkopf gives the same type of performance on the EMI set. They are both two of the most wonderful sopranos in history. Layout: Advantage: EMI! This is the biggest downfall of the DECCA set. Everything is lumped together, and most of the tracks are many minutes long. Le nozze di Figaro is a "number opera" and EMI has shorter tracks which make it much easier to skip the recititive if you wish to. Sound: Advantage: DECCA! Although the Giulini stereo holds up and sounds just fine, better than fine-it sounds great, the Solti recording is briliant in its digital power. Discs: Advantange: DECCA! The Giulini set had been knocked down to two discs because two arias have been discluded. I was going to say "non-descript" arias- but everything Mozart is amazing. These arias will not be missed though, they are sung by two of the more minor characters. However, it's Mozart and they are wonderful pieces, and the DECCA completeness is great. For any fan of this opera, not getting both the Giulini and Solti recordings is foolish. I adore and listen to them both very frequently. This is the most brilliant opera ever composed...and both recordings shine. I recommend both, but place the EMI set ahead of the DECCA set. Still, the DECCA set is an amazing recording and fully deserves FIVE STARS! Also, the Giulini recording of Don Giovanni is often regarding as the "greatest opera recording ever." Don't waste time on others. I've bought about five other Giovanni recordings and sold them all to used cd stores- there's no point-this is the only one.
|