Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Ballet for Band, December 4, 2003
These Mercury "Living Presence" recordings were a very special treat when they first appeared on vinyl.First of all, it was an opportunity to hear music from the ballet, "Pineapple Poll," that conductor/composer Sir Charles Mackerras created from tunes in various Gilbert and Sullivan operettas. There have been subsequent recordings of the full score, including at least one by Mackerras himself, but this suite is arranged for concert band and is given a first-rate performances by Frederick Fennell and the Eastman Wind Ensemble. For those of us who love Gilbert and Sullivan, hearing some of the familiar songs in instrumental versions is a special treat. We might even be tempted to sing the words to the songs we remember. In many ways, the story of the ballet takes the best elements of the Gilbert and Sullivan operettas, which followed a definite, very successful formula in the late nineteenth century. The master orchestrator Ottorino Resighi (1879-1936) arranged some of the late music by the master operatic composer Rossini for a special ballet, "La boutique fantastique," sometimes translated, "The fantastic toy shop." Many of these tunes were never published or performed in Rossini's lifetime; they were among the works Rossini wrote during his "retirement" in Paris, which he often referred to as "sins" of his old age. There are stories that Rossini even wrote tunes for his dog! In any case, Rossini continued to be a composer of memorable, delightful tunes and Respighi wonderfully arranged and orchestrated them. This is a very spirited, very enjoyable band arrangement of the music. The ballet music from Charles Gounod's "Faust" was an essential ingredient of the classic opera. As with any composer writing for the Paris Opera House, Gounod HAD to include a ballet, if only to please the members of the Jockey Club, who "patronized" the ballerinas who danced in the operas. Anyway, Gounod produced a number of memorable tunes for the ballet sequence, some of which are appropriately diabolical for an opera about the devil and his tempting of Faust. The band arrangement is a real treat and the Eastman musicians give it their best. I haven't heard the band arrangements of Wagner's music. I know that John Philip Sousa sometimes included such arrangements in his band concerts and, no doubt, Fennell has given the music its due. Wagner wrote extremely well for brass anyway, so much of his music lends itself to such arrangements. These performances are part of the continuing series of Mercury "Living Presence" recordings in outstanding digital remasterings. The original recordings spanned the years 1951 to 1968 and the vinyl releases were much desired and valued by record collectors over the years. Having them on compact discs assures that music-lovers in years to come will continue to enjoy these legendary performances.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Highly balanced and rich sound typical of Eastman, November 8, 1999
This in a fine CD. The Wagner pieces are rich, superbly balanced in the lower brass and horn sections (most notably). Furthermore, the Respighi La Boutique Fantasque, is a sleeper. One most often thinks of the "Pines" as the only symphonic band epic here. The ensemble does a great job with dynamics/contracts, a very interesting interpretation. I do prefer the impact of a "full" symphonic band versus an ensemble however in Elsa's Procession. The only CD/recording that I would suggest as an alternative would be in the University of Illinois Symphonic Band collection.It would give Eastman a run for the money, but you have to contact UI direct. You can't find the band recordings any more and therefore Eastman, as the most prolific symphonic training institution for brasses/winds, can't be beat in most cases.
|
|
|
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A delightful concert, May 2, 2008
I was searching for a recording of the Rossini-Resphigi score of La Boutique Fantasque when I came across this recording in a second hand shop. I generally enjoy Fennell's arrangements and took a flyer. It turned out to be a wise purchase and I haven't stopped playing it since I got it home.
Not only is the Rossini delightful, so is the Pineapple Poll Suite from Arthur Sullivan, part of the operetta pairing of Gilbert & Sullivan, a sequence of dancable numbers that will have you humming along with joy. I can't say as much for the Faust Ballet Music and don't know if its delicacies don't translate as well for wind band or whether it is simply not up to the standards set by the previous compositions.
The Wagner bleeding chunks for wind band that follow -- Lohengrin: Prelude To Act III and Elsa's Procession To The Cathedral -- are both worthwhile additions to the wind band discography. Not being a Wagnerite (even though I enjoy the occasional spin with a Stokowski recording of these bleeding chunks), I was unfamiliar with Elsa's procession, a piece that encapsulates all of this comoposer's erotica, passion and heroism in about six minutes.
The final track, Das Rheingold's Entry Of The Gods Into Valhalla, doesn't quite come off as well for wind band as it does for the likes of Karajan and Berlin Philharmonic, but it's fun and in keeping with the spirit of the goings-on.
As always from this source, the Mercury sound is just about perfect, with excellent fidelity, depth and definition. Why can't other companies do it this well? This recording is an hour's worht of fun and thrills for any fan of wind music. I would recommend this, especially at Amazon vendor prices, to anyone that thinks they may enjoy it...because you probably will.
|
|
|
|
~ Gustav Holst
~ Kenneth (F. J. Ricketts) Alford
~ John Philip Sousa
~ Eric [Composer] Coates
See all 21 tracks on this disc
- the new music site from IMDb and Amazon.
