|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Classic Badfinger, February 8, 2003
While most critics cite STRAIGHT UP as Badfinger's best album, this is the album I return to time and time again. Though technically their second album, it's the first to feature the classic lineup of Pete Ham, Tom Evans, Mike Gibbins and new guitarist Joey Molland. Peaking at No. 28 in the US (none of their albums charted in the UK!), it was their highest charting album."I Can't Take It" - The album kicks off with a straight-ahead Pete Ham rocker. "I Don't Mind" - A lovely Evans-Molland ballad, glorious harmonies. "Love Me Do" - A great rock 'n' roll song, but it didn't do anything to stop the Beatles comparisons when Molland titles his song with the same title as the Fab Four's first single! "Midnight Caller" - A lovely Pete Ham ballad. "No Matter What" - Another Pete Ham song, and the only single released from the album. (Peaked at No. 8.) "Without You" - Co-written by Ham and Evans. Could have been a huge single, and it was...for Harry Nilsson, who also won a Grammy for it. "Blodwyn" - This is one of my favorite songs, although I have no idea why a spoon would be "a token of my love." Ham's guitar work gives this song a distinctive country feel. "Better Days" - Another Evans/Molland collaboration. "It Had To Be" - Drummer Mike Gibbins is the underappreciated songwriter of the band. This is a lovely tune. "Watford John" - This little rocker is credited to the entire band. "Believe Me" - A wonderful Evans-penned ballad. "We're For the Dark" - A classic Pete Ham song which closed the original album on a somber note with its acoustic guitar. Best line: "But it's not enough to be/ If you gotta look, then you have to see." Then there are the five bonus tracks. [The final three were produced for a follow-up album to NO DICE that was never released. "Get Down" - A rocker written by the entire band. "Friends Are Hard To Find" - Another rocker penned by Molland. [Again he references the Beatles with the opening line: "Well, I had to laugh, I saw the photograph."} "Mean Mean Jemima" - Molland contributed this mid-tempo rocker. "Loving You" - Another gem from Gibbins. "I'll Be the One" - A final band collaboration and easily the best of the bonus tracks. With this album and its follow-up, 1971's STRAIGHT UP, Badfinger were establishing their own identity as a band and were poised for greatness. Tragically, it never happened. Label changes and bad business decisions and mismanagement saw declining record sales. "Baby Blue" and "Day After Day" from STRAIGHT UP would be their final Top 40 hits. WISH YOU WERE HERE only reached No. 148. By 1975 a despondent Pete Ham took his own life and brought a premature end to one of the most gifted bands of the era. This album serves as a testament to that greatness. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
|