|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great Performance, Spectacular Sound, Low Price, January 15, 2002
Others have commented on the performance. There are things I could imagine being done better -- Serafin, while generally excellent, can be a bit syrupy; I'd prefer a less thin-voiced and soubrettish Musetta than D'Angelo; the Schaunard muffs a couple of good comic opportunities. But overall, this has as high a standard of performance as any BOHEME recording -- and the best part is, it's an ALL-ITALIAN performance (or nearly all; I think D'Angelo may have been Italian-American), and it really does help, especially in the comic scenes, that all the singers know what they're singing about.Next, the sound. It took me a couple of listens to get used to the style of sound used here, but I soon came to be impressed by it, and finally to love it. The singers are not really distant; it's just that they're recorded in somewhat realistic perspective, as you might get in the opera house. This creates a real feeling of a stage picture, helped by the fact that the recording was "staged" in the studio: Most of the sound effects were done simultaneously with the music rather than being superimposed afterwards, and the stereo stage movement is meant to simulate a stage performance, so that you hear not only entrances and exits, but movements that correspond to all sorts of stage actions (though of course the singers are usually dead-center for their arias!). The sense of atmosphere conjured up by producer Erik Smith is quite phenomenal: The beginning of act 3, with the offstage and onstage action played out in differing perspectives, makes you almost feel like you're there watching and >feeling< it happen before you. Many audiophile friends of mine consider this the best-sounding opera recording ever made. I'm no audiophile, but I'm inclined to agree; in sonic terms it outclasses even Decca's Freni-Pavarotti recording, and runs rings around most of today's claustrophobic digital recordings. Even at full price, this would be my first choice among BOHEME recordings; at this price, it's one of the great bargains in the operatic catalogue (though you'll have to find a libretto and translation somewhere else).
|