Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
a noble experiment, August 23, 2004
Henry Kaiser has always been interested in the broader structures of improvisation. So when he and Wadada Leo Smith set out to produce a tribute to the great electric period of Miles Davis, they were trying to work his structures, not necessarily his sounds. And in that, they succeeded. During the era from Bitch's Brew up through the mid-1970s, Miles' music consisted basically of bass vamps and simple melodies against one and two chord harmonic structures. The basslines, melodies, and chord vamps could all be mixed and matched in different combinations as beds for extended improvisation. To this day, it remains one of the most insightful and exciting structures for improvisation yet developed, and shame on the jazz critics who shrug off this period as drug-addled noise, rather than the peak of Miles' career!
Henry Kaiser, Wadada Leo Smith, and various others set out to create new music within the framework Miles built, and in that they succeed. Long, creative improvisations over funky rhythmic beds characterize this work, and the soloists speak in their own voices. That's the good part.
The bad part, and why i'm only giving four stars, is that listening to this album just reminds us how incredibly brilliant Miles' work was. Yeah, this album is great, but it doesn't hold a candle to, say, Phaedra and Agharta, or Big Fun. They're standing in the long shadow Miles Davis cast.
Still, it's a lot of fun if you like this kind of music, and well worth the investment. But if you're not sure, then pick up some proper 1967-1975 electric Miles instead and prepare to be either amazed or boggled.
Thirty years ago, the music of Miles Davis sounded like it was from decades into the future. Today, the thirty year old music of Miles Davis STILL sounds futuristic! But hats off to this crew for trying to look into the future by looking into the past, and taking on a truly brave project that has to be measured against the finest work of one of the giants of music.
Oh, and as an added plus, this album has marvelous, insightful liner notes that will help you understand the music more. It's worth it for that alone.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
If you questioned Miles in the 70s, check this out!, September 8, 1998
At the time of Miles' 70s albums like Big Fun, Get Up With It, Live Evil, etc., while still pretty young (and therefore not tied into tradition), I found the music too chaotic (I was more into the ECM style, and 60s Miles). Having recently bought all the 70s reissues from CBS/Legacy, I found myself discovering things I would never have imagined there in the first place, it was with great interest that I saw an ad for Yo Miles!. I have always been a fan of Henry Kaiser (especially hist work with Richard Thompson), and thought that if anyone could do justice to this material, he could. I have not been disappointed. Yo Miles! is certainly a cleaner recording than the true 70s Miles material, partially because recording techniques are better, and partially because, while they are trying to reinterpret the material, they add a 90s sensibility, which I am sure Miles would have loved. The huge cast of players are excellent, and some of the medleys (especially Themes from Jack Johnson) are exceptionally well put together. Much like Miles, the grooves change, the tempos shift, and you can almost see Miles looking down giving his directions to the band. As another reviewer said, a great introduction to the period where everyone thought Miles had lost it. The reality is he hadn't lost it.....we had.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Reminds us how great this music was!, September 2, 1998
Miles purists often curl their lips at the churning, chaotic funk of his early seventies music, but Smith and Kaiser's CD (amazing value for money, a double for $20 or so) is a sharp reminder of how this primal roar captured the spirit of an era and paved the way for so much modern music. Highspots are the demented sax ensembles and solos, Kaiser's dead-on wah-and-graunch guitar stylings, and Smith's eerie grasp of what Miles was trying to do, but sometimes undershot. From the get-go, it doesn't sound like an imitation, but more of a tribute. Minor quibbles: Kaiser should have tossed the cheesy guitar-rack sitar effects and used a real sitar. And Smith plays just a bit too clean. But anyone who loved Miles will flip over this CD. And those who didn't, or were too young to get it: Hold on to your hats. This is the real classical music of the late 20th century.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Interact With Your Music: Discover, listen to, and buy new music, all from the pages of SPIN's digital edition, free to Amazon customers.
~ Henry Kaiser
~ Wadada Leo Smith
~ Various Artists
~ Ornette Coleman
~ Wadada Leo Smith
by Henry Kaiser 
