|
|
25 of 28 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A masterpiece; too bad about the remaster, August 22, 2000
The consensus (which happens to be true) is that Sinatra's best period was the middle one, the years he recorded for Capitol Records, 1953-61. His best Capitol material was the recordings he made with Nelson Riddle as arranger. Finally, Songs for Swingin' Lovers, from 1956, is with good reason considered to be the finest Sinatra/Riddle Capitol album, at least of a swinging, non-ballad sort. Personally, A Swingin' Affair, recorded later the same year but released in 1957, comes so close that it depends on which I've listened to most recently. Certainly, if you want to convince someone that, despite his boorish personality and many musical compromises, Sinatra DID sometimes record worthwhile music, you'd do well to play them Songs for Swingin' Lovers. This is also the album that fans most often throw on the stereo when they don't want to pick nits about production, arrangements, vocals, or song selection. Everything came together perfectly---Sinatra was at his vocal peak, in simpatico settings, interpreting some of the best songs of Tin Pan Alley, and brimful of confidence and spotaneity. There's just the right mixture of tenderness and swagger; listen to the rendition of "I've Got you Under My Skin", which counts as one of the four or five best Sinatra performances on record. "You're Getting To Be A Habit With Me," "Too Marvelous For Words," "I Thought About You", "Swingin' Down the Lane," "Anything Goes," "How About You?"---so many of the songs here are top-drawer, both as songs and performances, that it's mind-boggling. And there are a lot of them too---15 songs in all, uncommonly generous for the early LP era. Too generous for Capitol, which released mutilated versions of this and other Sinatra albums (Swingin' Affair also initially sported 15 tracks) amputating several songs from American pressings for decades. The true, original versions of these masterpieces were only available as imports form British EMI until the CD editions came out in 1987. Now I read from some of these Amazon reviews that these albums have suffered a further indignity by being reissued in "remastered" editions that sound terrible. I thank God that I finally bought a CD copy of SFSL a year or two BEFORE the botched remaster was dumped on the market. It's a sad and frustrating development, but much as I'd like to blame Capitol, I think we have Sinatra's daughter Tina to thank for this. She has control of the estate, the business, and most importantly, the music. I'm sure that when the decision was made to dun the public with a remaster of Frank's albums, Tina left no corner uncut. What a shame. So get the OLDER CD (with the black left border), or get a used British EMI vinyl pressing, or get a beat-up fifties copy, or get a tape of this from a friend. Accept no substitutes, for in it's original, unabbreviated, un-20-bit-botched configuration, Songs For Swingin' Lovers is nonpareil.
|