|
|
10 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Surprisingly good, but not quite his best, June 10, 2003
By A Customer
Most artists shouldn't have collections of outtakes and unreleased songs, but most nowadays do. Often they're disappointing. You have to be very prolific and very good to make them worthwhile. You also have to be a questionable arbiter of your own material to keep such good material off your "official releases" (something Bob Dylan's been accused of). But, there is a reason why Springsteen, like Prince, Neil Young, and Dylan, is widely bootlegged, and not just for his amazing concerts. He is prolific, he is very good. BUT, he is a pretty good judge of his own material. A few lapses, but he still bats close to a 1.000.The set starts off with a few demos. Here's a young man, hungry, ambitious, exploding with nervous energy and ideas, rushing through his songs on just his voice and an acoustic guitar. Upon repeated listening, they pale to the live, full-band versions, all except "Growin' Up." A great, great version. Next up, a great live cut, "Bishop Danced," just Bruce with Federici on accordian. It's a lost classic, and so is "Thundercrack." "Seaside Bar Song" is a good-time, swinging record, but "Santa Ana," "Zero...," and "Linda..." don't take off, lyrically or musically. I almost turn off the record, but then things pick up with the lost classic "Thundercrack." The best of the rest, a rocking live "Rendezvous," the retro, pile-driving "Give The Girl A Kiss" and "So Young...," the slow, romantic "Hearts Of Stone," and a slow, brooding "Iceman" are all good, but they don't match what you find on "Darkness On The Edge Of Town" or "The River." Either it's not quite as good or thematically, it clashes too much, or both. On a few, Bruce doesn't get through the whole song without botching the lyrics (luckily, they print them up for you). Still, a song like "Restless Nights" has a killer guitar break even if it isn't one of Bruce's best songs. The middle of the set is sustained by some excellent B-sides from the singles off the "Born In The USA" Lp, but the stand-out is the acoustic version of that Lp's title track. It takes the song somewhere darker, more disturbing, and ultimately saves the song from being hijacked as a widely-misinterpeted arena anthem. Bruce's 'cars and girls' songs are getting better, too. By 1978, they already transformed into social commentary, anger, and frustration instead of the retro, romanticism of his early years, but as you can see from the outtakes, he was still writing and recording some in that mold as late as 1984. But, again, he had outgrown them, so the nice, romantic "Frankie" gets shelved and the swaggering "Pink Cadillac" is banished to B-side purgatory. This is where the pickings get slim, and Bruce nearly hits a brick wall. Most of the last disc is generic sounding. They're not bad, but they cover well-worn territory. If they were musically more compelling, he'd get away with that, but they aren't. They sound generic. Still, "Sad Eyes" creates a nice mood, as does "Happy." The last track, "Brothers..." (unrelated to the similarly titled song on Disc 3), however, ends the set on a high note. Not a lost classic, but better than anything on the "Tom Joad" album. Just excellent. Had his effective, underrated re-recording of "The Promise" and "Missing" been included here instead of being banished to "18 Tracks" and a Europe-only CD single, respectively, the last quarter would've been so much better. The former is a lost classic (previously recorded in intolerably slow versions), the latter a strong latter day song exploring new ground (done for a movie directed by Sean Penn). "The Fever" should've been here, too (also on "18 Tracks"). Bruce's studio albums from "Wild, Innocent..." to "Tunnel Of Love" are all very good to great. Each one had been called a masterpiece by somebody, and dropping the songs you hear on "Tracks" doesn't hurt them. But, one could have a very respectable career had they recorded the music you hear on "Tracks."
|