|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Awesome, August 13, 2002
There is no real explaining how good this cd is. If I had to destroy all of my albums but one I would probably keep this one. First of all, it's a double album containing over 2 hours of music which I got for the price of a single album, with the greatest consistency of any album I own, except possibly Aenima. Buy it. Buy it now, especially if you don't own any Iced Earth. Now, with that gushing aside I'll go into an actual review.As stated in an earlier review, I am generally not big on live albums. The problems that plague most of them are not significant here. The fans sing along some, which is occasionally a problem, and their perpetual chanting of "Iced Earth" between songs can be kind of annoying, but they usually don't matter too much. The sound quality is excellent, which it usually isn't, and the bands performances are flawless. Smedley's drumming is particularly good, better than on most of the albums. The one real complaint against the album is that most of the songs aren't substantially different from the original versions, though I consider them different enough that this cd is completely worth owning despite my having the studio versions of every song but one. Though this album is perhaps the most consistent I own, I will still complain about the track listing a little. The excellent album, Burnt Offerings, is under represented, with only 2 tracks(though one is extremely long, 16 minutes) and none of them being the classic title track or "Diary" or "Brainwashed". A handful of other classics are missing, like "Consequences", "Disciples of The Lie" and worst of all "Scarred", which is especially annoying because it does include the other 2 songs of the "Suffering" trilogy, so it messes up the continuity of it, not to mention it's simply being an awesome song. The thing is, though some other songs should be on here, only one song, "Melancholy", seems like it would be an acceptable loss. This cd does contain an excellent overview of the bands career up to with just under half of the album being from before "The Dark Saga", and the rest from that point on, which is good because that marked a distinct change in the bands style. Sadly, it of course contains no songs from "Horror Show", since it wasn't even released yet, but there is already too much material from the earlier albums to be compiled here. The earlier stuff is very "Master of Puppets" and "...And Justice For All" esque, except generally even more complex, though with a bit more melody as well. This music benefits from the new recording, because the original versions sound quality is a little flat and sterile, even in the "Days of Purgatory" versions, with the "Stormrider" material being much more intense and powerful. The best stuff from this era are generally the longest ones, such as the 10 minute "Angels Holocaust/Stormrider" the 9 minute "Travel In Stygian" and the 16 minute "Dante's Inferno", with the shorter "Path I Choose" also being particularly strong. The later stuff is slower, simpler, shorter and more melodic, though with a greater variety of song types, since the early songs are almost all prog-thrash epics. The Ballads, "A Question of Heaven" and "Watching Over Me" are among the best from this era, with the faster, heaviest songs on the opposite end of the spectrum being the next strongest, particularly "The Last Laugh", "Slave to the Dark" and "Burning Times". Thus this album has a great variety of songs, as much so as is possible while having all of them being rooted in 80's underground metal. Lyrically, this all comes off a bit weird, as it has three different storylines from concept albums all interweaved together, but this doesn't matter much, as Iced Earth has alway been about sound, not message. So what does this all come done to? It's a compilation of most of the best material by arguably the best band ever. So, once again, buy it, buy it NOW!
|