Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
101 of 104 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
You'll Never Believe This Is A Tribute Album., January 12, 2000
RETURN OF THE GRIEVOUS ANGEL is far too good for the tribute album stamp. Tribute albums are known for being notoriously bad, offering second or third rate version of songs by an artist, with arrangements similar to the originals. However, none of this is present on this exceptional album. Part of the reason might be the strenght of Gram Parsons's song. Another might be the fact that the ultra-talented Emmylou Harris served as executive producer. The artists who made the recordings also have a remarkable amount of talent listed in order of appearence on the record: The Pretenders, Emmylou Harris, The Cowboy Junkies, Beck, Evan Dando, Julianna Hatfield, The Mavericks, Chris Hillman, Steve Earle, Sheryl Crow, Elvis Costello, Lucinda Williams, David Crosby, Wilco, Whiskeytown, Gillian Welch, The Rolling Creekdippers. The arrangements of these songs are intriging, and perfectly performed. "She" is a beautiful song, which sounds natural, but not identical to, the arrangements of Gram Parson's original. "Ooh Las Vegas" is completely re-worked, which is a brand new sound experience, sounding almost other worldy. "Sin City" is an outstanding duet, when hearing this for the first time, I got a clearer meaning of the song. "$1,000 Wedding" is a beautiful, and powerful song. The Mavericks give "Hot Burrito #1" a new great flavor, keeping the song fresh and eager. My second favorite on the album (next to the title track) is "High Fashion Queen" sung by the brilliant talents of Chris Hillman and Steve Earle. The song is great country-rock music, and flawlessly written. Emmylou Harris and Sheryl Crow sound like angels performing "Juanita", the harmonies are gorgeous. Elvis Costello delievers a marvelous version of "Sleepless Nights", the only cover version on the tribute album. My favorite song on the album is "Return Of The Grievous Angel", the title track of Gram Parsons's last masterpiece. Lucinda Williams and David Crosby magnificently re-work the song, and deliever a fantastic track. It sounds almost like it belongs on Lucinda Williams's CAR WHEELS ON A GRAVEL ROAD (also HIGHLY RECOMMENDED). Wilco also marvelously re-works another masterpiece "One Hundred Years From Now". The song here is a straight-out, full-fledged rocker. The majestic "A Song For You" is an emotional song, beautifully performed by Whiskeytown. Gillian Welch performs a gorgeous version of the classic masterpiece "Hickory Wind". "Hickory Wind" is so wonderful, there can't be a way to ruin a song this perfect. The Rolling Creekdippers close the CD on an inspirational note with "In My Hour Of Darkness". No matter what kind of music you love, you'll be satisfied by RETURN OF THE GRIEVOUS ANGEL. After listening to music this good, some of my CDs now pale in comparison. After hearing and buying RETURN OF THE GRIEVOUS ANGEL, I've made a point of buying the original Gram Parson's albums: SAFE AT HOME (with the International Submarine Band), SWEETHEART OF THE RODEO (with The Byrds), THE GILDED PALACE OF SIN and BURRITO DELUXE (with The Flying Burrito Brothers), and GP/GRIEVOUS ANGEL (by Gram Parsons). This is music at its best, just one listen and you'll agree.
|
|
|
27 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Simply the Best of the Gram Tribute recordings to Date, December 9, 1999
By A Customer
Isn't it a little outragious that we now have not only this wonderful tribute Album but three others to choose from after spending untold years combing through Import Bins to find yet another elusive Gram Parsons or Burrito Bros Track? All the sudden there is a Gram-Glut, but.. you don't hear me complaining! If you are new to your Gram-Fandom, this here is the first Tribute Album you should buy for several reasons: First, this one gathers together a unique blend of the most memorable Gram tunes performed by a group of artists who inherited the mantle he passed on. Other Tribute recordings have a more varied mix of performers and the renditions of the songs do not always sound "Gram-like" or even true to the origins of the material. The second reason to start with this one is that it is the only one Produced by Emmylou Harris, Gram's singing Partner in life and star in her own right. She brings an honesty to the production and hearing her familiar harmonies with other singers on Gram Standards lends a very authentic feel. The third reason is simply the recording quality. The sound on this CD is pure and clear. I found the others to be a little less so and muddy at times with the quality from track to track varying wildly. Not so here, each track shines on its own. I was very surprised by Emmylou and Beck's version of SIN CITY since it varied so greatly from Emmylou's earlier rendition on one of her own albums. This time she opts to sing an alto harmony. Very nice. As someone who collects all versions of SIN CITY, suffice it to say, I am a connosieur of this song and this version is one of the best I have heard. I now rank it my number two fave version after the original. My third fave version is Emmylou's original and my fourth is Dwight Yoakum and kd lang's. I could go on but I won't. Start here and you won't be sorry. This is a standout.
|
|
|
18 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
He'd be proud..., November 30, 1999
I eagerly awaited the release of this album and now that I have been kicking it around for a couple of months, I feel that the time is right for a few comments. Ahem, here goes...Unlike the other Gram tribute on the market (Conmemorativo - A Tribute to Gram Parsons, Rhino Records 1993, go have a browse, it's sure to be here somewhere), the versions of Parson's songs are mostly faithful readings of the originals. Sometimes that works, (Sheryl Crow's and Emmylou's Juanita is spine-tingling); sometimes it is just karaoke. (Mr Dando, please stand up). Wilco's version of 100 Years From Now is fabulous. It shows the quality of the song; if in doubt, slip on Sweetheart of the Rodeo and listen to the original alongside it. (Incidentally, if you have not heard Conmemorativo, it is worth getting just for Something Happens' version of Brass Buttons) One of Gram's strengths was his delivery, the way he sang his own songs or inpterpreted others. I have heard many different versions of I'm Your Toy, but nothing comes near the original. Why try to improve on perfection? Sin City has by now been covered to death, and the version on Gilded Palace of Sin is still the best. If this album introduces more people to the delights of Gram's music, it will have done a fine job.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|