|
|
39 of 47 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Golden, June 10, 2000
If I could only have five Bowie CDs, "Station to Station" would round out the list. It is a virtual Bowie music primer in that it pulls together more elements of his ever-changing style than any other album. The songs are good, but they work even better together-the whole is stronger than its component parts."Diamond Dogs" was a transitional album between Bowie's glam and disco phases. "Station to Station" is transitional on the other side of the disco moment (epitomized by "Young Americans"). This one bridges 70's dance music to the new wave style that would come into its own with the "Berlin Trilogy" of "Low," "'Heroes'," and "Lodger," and reached its zenith with the excellent "Scary Monsters." Songs like the title track, "Station to Station" recall some of the bizarre mystic references that pop up on "The Man Who Sold the World." "TVC15" has choppy, paranoid, non-sequitur lyrics like those on "Diamond Dogs." "Golden Years," the albums pop hit, would have fit well on the earlier "Young Americans" or the later "Let's Dance." "Stay" has the dark and confused undertones that characterize "Low." So, fans of almost any other Bowie album will find something they like on "Station to Station." The album opens with the highly original title song. At over ten minutes, it is Bowie's longest studio song, and one of his most complex. Immediately he demonstrates what a synthesizer can do by mimicking the sound of a train taking off from a station. Like the train, the song starts slowly before building to a full steam. "Station to Station" is an asymmetrical song - the pace, the melody, and everything else go through a gradual transformation from the start to the end. Despite this transformation and the symbolism of the title, the song itself is not necessarily about transition. After listening to it for years and years I'm still not exactly sure what it is about. It is deliberately confused - like Bowie is trying to describe something that he's having trouble putting words to. He's feeling something, but he's not sure what. He rules out drugs - "Its not the side effects of the cocaine," before tentatively concluding, "I'm thinking that it must be love." So is he speculating about a feeling, or an event? Some of the lyrics hint at a forced separation. He may be trying to make sense of such an occurrence, perhaps because of a war. In this sense there are vague links to "Aladdin Sane," which itself draws on World War I imagery. Then there are the mystical references, "Here are we, one magical movement from Kether to Malkuth," (a line related to the picture of Bowie drawing "the Tree of Life" on the back of the CD package). "Station to Station" is the only song that mentions The Thin White Duke, which many assume was the newest Bowie persona. That isn't entirely clear from the song. All we know from the song is that the Duke has returned, throws darts in lovers eyes (whatever that means) and makes sure "white stains." The Duke is not necessarily the narrator of the song. It could be a metaphor. It could be cocaine. It could be another World War I reference. It could mean nothing at all. Whatever it all means, it works well and is a worthy kickoff to the album. The next song is about as different as possible. "Golden Years" is the most accessible song on the album, and it's only hit single. It is a straightforward, positive, nothing song combining a disco beat with a 50's do-wop sound. "Drive in Saturday" meets "Fame." Rumor has it that Bowie originally wrote the song for Elvis Presley, who rejected it. "Golden Years" is catchy, but it is the weakest song on the album. It sounds good at first, but is simply not as enduring or thought provoking as the other songs. Bowie is typically at his worst when he's trying to sing happy, as with the songs "Kooks" and "Fill Your Heart" that mar "Hunky Dory." Its over quickly, then we're back to the more complex with "Word on a Wing." Bowie toys with religion from time to time in some of his songs. "Word on a Wing" is his most sincere and overall best treatment of the subject. In the song he tries to reconcile his faith with the rest of his life. Bowie concludes, "Just because I believe don't mean I don't think as well, don't have to question everything in heaven and hell." But the tentativeness of much of the rest of the album is present on this song as well. This is not a sermon, it is an attempt to figure things out. Bowie can't figure anything out in the next song. "TVC15." "TVC15" is barely discernable as a song about a girlfriend getting consumed by a television. It's really an expression of paranoia, and the encroachment of television on personal relations. It is also the most tongue-in-cheek song on the album, but musically it is one of the strongest. "Stay" is the next song. Again, Bowie sounds deliberately confused. This time he's wrestling with whether a partner should stay the night or not. One can imagine the response to the song being "Should I stay or should I go." Bowie seems to realize that, if she (he?) stays there could be trouble. "Stay" sharply contrasts with the certainty and confidence of "Let's Spend the Night Together," which Bowie weakly covers on "Aladdin Sane." As with his spirituality, Bowie is unsure about his sexuality. At least until the closing song, "Wild is the Wind." "Wild is the Wind" is both one of Bowie's most successful covers and also one of his best (really, one of his only) ballads. The song is a few steps away from being corny, but it somehow works and sounds beautiful at the end of "Station to Station." There is no uncertainty in this song. It is a profound expression of love, and a good way to end the album. All of this meshes very well together. "Station to Station" is a collection of songs, not a concept album, but it has a pleasing continuity despite the theme of uncertainty. Aside from the weakness of "Golden Years," the album's only other shortcoming is that it's too short. Although the six songs are long, the entire album (minus bonus tracks) contains less than 38 minutes. But it is a very good 38 minutes. As usual, the "bonus songs" on the Rykodisk version of "Station to Station" add nothing. If you have the EMI version, which duplicates the original, you are missing live versions of "Word on a Wing" and "Stay," two songs that you just heard. The live versions are slightly longer, but sound very much like the studio versions. They are not bad, but they are unnecessary.
|