Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
86 of 89 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Beauty beyond comprehension, November 16, 2001
It took me a little while to get "into" this CD. This is simplicity to the maximum. I don't like calling this music "minimalism" because that to me insinuates minimal cerebral content. This disc is totally the opposite of that...there's so much to chew on here that its astonishing.The melody is absolutely gorgeous and almost forces one into instrospection and contemplation. This album is very cleansing for me as I almost wind up in tears every time I put it on. This fills a very import space in music today in my opinion. So much of today's classical music is cacophonous, dissonant, filled with aural "fireworks" or just plain weird (I have no problems with any of those things.) This however, is none of those things. It is calm, simple, beautiful and still. Our world doesn't stand still enough. This isn't sappy or new age (both things which I can't stand) its just simple and good. The disc does have an odd configuration. "Spiegel Im Spiegel" is on the disc three times. Once with cello & piano and twice with violin & piano. "Fur Alina" a piece for solo piano is on there twice. The program notes are interesting in that "Fur Alina" was actually a several hour improvisation, and Part himself selected two phases from it to insert between the three renditions of "Spiegel Im Spiegel." This to me, really heightens the difference between the two pieces. I think there a lot of metaphysical overtones with the pieces (i.e. life's phases, etc.) Considering these were some of Part's first works after his self imposed silence, I think Part's new affinity for triads probably makes some allusions to Greek monk St. Gregory Palamas' book "Triads." That is totally my own conjecture, but considering Part's interest in Eastern Christianity it makes sense to me. Anyway, to make a long story short, get this CD if you are open to silence and space and contemplation. If you are looking for the sweeping majesty of some of Part's other works, it won't be found here.
|
|
|
65 of 70 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The simple beauty of it, February 20, 2000
I have had a hard time coming up with words for this CD. It is probably the most beautiful work of music I own. I am not exaggerating. The tintinnabuli style has an ephemeral feel to which other works only aspire. I noticed after the third or fourth time listening to it that the silence is as essential to the music; I felt myself reaching for the next note. It's beautiful, simply beautiful. I think of the movie The Hunger when I hear it, for that movie had piano and cello pieces in it also. The images that one saw in it, that of light and gossamer drapes floating go through my mind when I hear this. This CD is worth anything one must pay to get it. It truly is a work of genius.
|
|
|
20 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
This is not about Alina, November 16, 2002
I would urge everyone to own this cd and it will soon own you too, heart and soul. I won't comment on the ad nauseum tintinnabulism or , god forbid , minimalism. The former just does not apply here ( see Fratres, Festina lente, Summa, Cantus , etc. --- all wonderful works --- for that). Alina is about as minimalist as , say , Fur Elise or Traumerei. But this is all about Spiegel im Spiegel, neither tinntinabulist nor minimalist, merely pure genius; perhaps the greatest short piece for violin and piano ( two lovers singing) in the 20th C. Heed the title : Mirror in Mirror : you'll be looking back at your yourself looking back and again until mesmerized by one of the most achingly beautiful pieces ever wrought. That is the good news. However none of these three interpretaions is the definitive one. If you like your beauty neat, you will, seek out PROU CD 139. Here Arvo Part is fully realized in all his splendour recorded in a chapel , fittingly, by Baltic musicians with other Baltic Music--- most noteably Schnittke's Violin Sonata #1. If this recording doesn't tear your eyes, you just aren't human. Alina is , yes, wonderful, but for the greatest S. im S reach further. It is worth it indeed !
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|