|
|
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A true-life tale of bravery beyond the call of duty, September 1, 2001
I purchased and watched "The Hunley" to increase my knowledge of this Confederate submarine and her brave crew. I have been following the actual excavation of the Hunley since it was recovered from the silt of Charleston Bay, and the remains of its crew, including Lt. George E Dixon, have now been found. Right where Dixon's pocket used to be, they found the gold coin given to him by his sweetheart, the coin that stopped a bullet and saved his life at Shiloh, a real event that is presented in the film.The movie of the Hunley necessarily had to add dramatic and fictional elements, and for the most part, they were enjoyable. The crew includes an angry Irishman who likes to fight, an Englishman who doesn't, and a groom who misses his wife. As comic relief perhaps, a young Confederate soldier begs to join the crew and tries to impress Dixon and Beauregard by regularly jumping into the sea fully dressed and splashing about. He is finally accepted. Why would a third crew attempt to man the Hunley when two previous crews drowned? The film answers that by showing the increasing desperation of the residents of Charleston as offshore Union battleships regularly bombard the blockaded city. The only hope of victory over the overwhelming opposing force is to strike an effective blow against the Yankee Navy, and the Hunley does it, sinking the USS Housatonic with a spear-mounted torpedo. The sub, however, never returned to port, ending the hope for victory. The film speculates as to what might have happened following the Hunley's first and last mission. Armand Assante is a fine actor, and does a credible job portraying the determined George E Dixon. However, Lt. George E Dixon, was much younger (in his early 20s), was blonde and over six feet tall. Knowing that fact did not help me to appreciate Assante's portrayal, as I like authenticity. At the end of the film I felt both sadness and admiration for the lost crew of the Hunley. Bravery and valor are not always rewarded with success or fame, but at last the crew has come home for burial. God bless them.
|