Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
42 of 43 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not just a soundtrack, it's a great Elton John album, April 7, 2000
The negative comments of other customers are quite amazing, particularly those which suggest that "real" fans should steer clear of this album. To my mind, as a "real" fan for nearly twenty years, this is certainly one of Elton's best albums, especially in the last 10 - 12 years. Patrick Leonard has done a great job of elevating Elton's voice and piano to the front of the mix, a production value lost by Chris Thomas, whose overblown drum and synth work has dogged good songs since 1992. Best tracks on here include "Eldorado", the first single "Someday Out of the Blue", "Queen of Cities" and the brilliant "Friends Never Say Goodbye" which features the Backstreet Boys on uncredited backing vocals. I judge a new Elton album by how long it stays in my CD player before I revert to older material. This one has been there since release day, and shows no signs of leaving. The songs fit together very well, and Elton is obviously enjoying the experience of writing to Tim Rice's lyrics. I can honestly say there isn't any track on here that shouldn't be. Amazon should include this as an essential recording by Elton John - a return to the form he reached with 1995's "Made in England". I look forward to the next John/Taupin album, which Patrick Leonard is producing - they are back in the studio in September.
|
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Elton John's Triumphant Return to Excellence!, April 2, 2000
FIRST and foremost, this incredible collection of songs, some heard in the new animated feature film, Dreamworks "The Road to El Dorado" is NOT an original soundtrack recording. Although nine of the fourteen songs are heard in the film, six of them are heard in a different, less compelling presentation than performed here. With that said, this project is the most recent Elton John album proper since the majestic "The Big Picture" album released in 1997. For those Elton John fans of his seventies era, he hasn't re-recorded the "Goodbye Yellow Brick Road" album. He's been there, done that. Although he discovered ballads and the adult contemporary sound during the eighties and nineties, his use of the format is to impressive degrees on this project. For the first time since "Captain Fantastic" Elton's music actually sounds inspired as does his performance of these impressive songs. Elton has matured and his taste in music has developed and grown with him. His collaboration with Tim Rice is triumphant, a first since the union for Disney's "The Lion King". Their attempt to compose for the stage, although noble, was completely trashed by hideous performances in their last project "Aida". On this opus, Elton handles all the singing. The only guest vocalist is Randy Newman on the hilarious "It's Tough To Be A God". Two of the most impressive songs "16th Century Man" and "Trust Me" are NOT heard in the film at all. In addion, "My Heart Dances" and "Queen of Cities" as impressive as they are were not used for the film. No matter, this album is not a soundtrack intended to remind of favorite sequences from the film. Rather, the album plays out in the manner appropriate for an original Elton John project proper. The final three tracks on the cd are compositions from the picture, however they fit like a glove in the context of the theme of the project. "Without Question" and "The Panic in Me" are sublime Elton John. The animated film itself is impressive, however this collection is purely Elton John's triumph and welcome return to glory.
|
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Songs are NOT from the actual movie, October 20, 2005
I believe the above has been stated in at least a couple reviews, but I somehow missed it in perusing the reviews before I purchased this album, and I want it stressed that this album does not contain the actual recordings used in the movie El Dorado. The tunes are the same, some lyrics are different (a minor quibble) but most upsetting is if you're looking for a recapturing of the songs you heard while watching the movie, you're not going to get it here. I LOVE the film version of "It's tough to be a god" with Ken and Kevin singing it, and while the Elton/Randy Newman version also is cute, it just doesn't have the same 'oomph'. The title theme is weak compared to the version heard in the movie, and I was really disappointed that the lively female backing vocals heard in the movie version of "The trail we blaze" are completely missing from this CD and replaced instead by breathy male backup. Compared to the movie, the songs on the CD are of a notably slower tempo and calmer delivery (read: a bit boring). My children are more forgiving than I, and enjoy the CD anyhow, and the additional tracks feature some really great music ("16th century man" is a great catchy upbeat tune if you ignore the somewhat silly lyrics). Just be sure you know what to expect!
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Interact With Your Music: Discover, listen to, and buy new music, all from the pages of SPIN's digital edition, free to Amazon customers.
~ Elton John
~ Doctors of Madness
DVD ~ Kevin Kline
~ Elton John
~ Eddie Holman
by Elton John 
