Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Terrific time travel tales!!!, August 16, 2005
These may be two of the best Dr. Who eps of all time. Baker really had begun hitting his stride, moving outside the script from time to time. Elisabeth Sladen was one of the few companions who could actually keep up with him in these deviations, although ultimately all companions are "screamers." If you're looking for their best work together, you might want to find a copy of Pyramid of Mars, but back to the topics at hand...
Genesis is classic BBC story telling at its best, written and performed at a time when many broadcast writers had done (and continued) to write for radio. However, 'Who' was benefitting from some excellent set work, with directors who understood that tight settings with the right props could create a huge image in the viewer's mind when budgets and technology did not allow for the kind of FX we now are used to.
Our heros are forced to challenge their views of right and wrong, and over how far one may have to go to deal with great evil. Secondary characters provide stories of craven collaboration and heroic challenges to authority.
This story also is a good example of why the Daleks became such a fascinating topic over and over again for Doctor Who. Ultimately, they (like evil) never are completely defeated. They have no mercy, only their goal of creating a perfect, Dalek society.
The Sontaran Experiment is a little more of a straight forward adventure yarn, again populated by interesting sub characters. The Sontarans, despite their technology and vast numbers, inevitably succumb to their own rigidity. A much better Sontaran episode emerges down the road, when the Doctor becomes president of Galifry, only to turn the whole plant over to the Sontarans!
These two tales should make almost anyone a fan of Doctor Who, and the whole Tom Baker era represents much of the best of what that show ever offered.
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
An excellent set and a great place to get "into" Dr. Who, February 24, 2000
This two tape set is a great place to start into Doctor Who. First, you get the Sontaran experiment. The story is short, interesting, and good enough to "whet the appetite," so to speak. And the Harry/Sarah/Doctor combination is excellent.Genesis of the Daleks is a fabulous story to be caught up in. An intricate tale that is both brutal and sophisticated. Michael Wisher as Davros and Peter Miles as Nyder play their parts to perfection, able to convey their manipulative characters with authenticity. This is also a great place to learn of the Daleks as this is perhaps, without a doubt, their best story. Buy this one with confidence!
|
|
|
5 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the best bakers of all time!, June 6, 1999
By A Customer
The first story here is The Sontaran Experiment. Sadly, it's rather pointless, and Kevin Lindsay - no matter what Sarah Jane says - looks decidedly different to Linx (his colour, for instance - and his extra finger!!!). The human cast are rathe weak, and Styre's robot looks silly and gets little to do. The fact that story was shot entirely on location is great after the studio-bound Ark In Space. Tom Baker manages well to hide his apparent neck brace (after braking his collar bone somehow, so I'm told) and his performance is brilliant. I suppose it's just an interlude between Ark In Space and the next story, better in every way... Genesis Of The Daleks was a good comeback for the Daleks, after the rather shaky Death To The Daleks. The first Tom Baker story which really caught my attention, it is well written, and Michael Wisher does an outstanding performance as the insane, yet evil Davros. Harry Sullivan is irritating as usual, and Sarah Jane just walks off and befriends the "Mutos" (a rather silly name, like "Norm." Well, I think so....). Tom Baker was really dramatic as the Doctor - a clear sign that he has long since settled into the role of the now superb Fourth Doctor. On the whole, superb.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|