|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Delineation Between Characters and "Golden Age" Singing, December 8, 2000
This, Ms. Fleming's latest recital for London/Decca, is a wonderful glimpse of a "full lyric" soprano in her prime. Her interpretations are heartfelt and all are imbued with an incredible amount of humanity, she inhales life into this gallery of characters. Granted, this is a bit of a compilation disc in that everyone has heard most of these arias sung by at least three different "divas"; however, in some cases, these interpretations will make you forget all others.She begins with "O mio babbino caro", possibly the shortest aria in all of the soprano repertoire, but certainly one of the most emotional. Her Lauretta is plaintive and gorgeously sung. Initially, I found the audible breaths taken after nearly every phrase distracting but after comparing this aria with the others on the disc and seeing that she has absolutely no trouble with aspirated singing elsewhere, I realized they functioned merely as an effective means of expression. Immediately following this resounding success is another in the form of "Un bel di", the frequently excerpted aria from Puccini's MADAMA BUTTERFLY. It is shorn of its recitative, Ms. Fleming opts instead to dive directly to the core of the character. From this reading, the listener gets the sense that Butterfly knows she's been deserted but speaks optimistically of her lover's return as a means of consolation to herself and her maid, Suzuki. Ms. Fleming's technique is so secure that there is no hint of vocal strain as she builds elegantly to a wonderfully executed climax. Up until now, my favorite versions of Liu's "Signore, ascolta" have been those done by Callas and (Leontyne) Price, respectively. Callas because she delivered the goods dramatically speaking, and Price because hers was a version that was beautifully vocalized. Renee Fleming somehow is able to do both, delivering beautiful pianissimi while never losing focus of the aria's dramatic heft. And wait until you hear that final note. It is so long that you will be gasping for her, it only ends when the orchestra does. Whether this is as it was originally written or just a flourish I do not know, but it is thrilling nonetheless. The excerpts from MANON are without peer and she sings the last "adieu" of "Adieu, notre petite table" with so much pathos that it will make you weep. I'd be remiss if I did not mention the last track on the CD, Verdi's "Bolero". She starts out a bit tentatively but the timidity soon vanishes as she takes long phrases with excellent breath control and confidence. She finishes with a thrilling, open-throated high D that you have to hear (many times!) to believe. Her diction is admirable throughout and Sir Mackerras lends able support, on occasion you'll think he must be communicating with Ms. Fleming telepathically they work so well together. Of course, no CD is perfect and, that being the case, I'd be dishonest if I didn't mention that her versions of "Je veux vivre" (her voice is too heavy and the fiorature is executed with more than its share of sluggishness) and "Casta Diva" (her use of legato in this aria is seamless but that is about all I can say that is positive) are not ideal; however, these are only blemishes on a thoroughly satisfying and beautiful recital.
|