|
|
26 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Magic of Bagger Vance!, November 10, 2000
I must first say that this is the third score of Rachel Portman's that I have, and she keeps getting better every time! The first I got was "Emma", which is nice orchestal music, and pleasant to listen to. However, it all seemed pretty much the same, with little depth and life to it. I hardly listen to it anymore. The next I got, "The Cider House Rules", was much better, and had more depth and emotion to it. It is one that I have listened to on a fairly regular basis, and really enjoy.So, when I read from anpother reputable film score reviewer (Probably the same one as the reviewer mentions below) that this was even better, and was in fact one of the best he'd heard, I looked forward to listening to it. I actually saw the movie first, and loved the music in the movie, and it made the movie, in so many ways. When I listened to the score I had to agree: this is one of the best scores I've ever heard, and that's from almost 150! It is much more full of depth, life, and emotion than even "The Cider House Rules" was, and the main theme is very beautiful! Another thing about this score that is different than Portman's previous scores, is the different themes in it. Generally she only uses one main theme and variations in her scores, but that is not the case here. It does still sound like Rachel Portman though, who, for all the talk about James Horner re-hashing his own scores, does much more of that than Horner even does. But I do not consider that a negative. I look at it like the growth of a child into an adult: you go from being a kid, to a teen, to an adult, but you still look very similar to how you did when you were a kid, and you're still pretty much the same. It's a matter of maturity, and that's what I see here in Rachel Portman's music. "Emma" is like the "Kid", "The Cider House Rules" is like the "Teen", and "The Legend of Bagger Vance" is like the "Adult", mature. We are seeing the maturing of Rachel Portman as a composer, and her music reflects that. I could go into details of the music, and what it sounds like, but you should really hear that for yourself, because I can't do it justice. It IS very introspective and inspirational, and I definitely recommend getting this score if you like music at all. It's not just one I listen to a lot, it's right up there among the top of my list of favorites. The only thing keeping me from saying it's the best score of the year is the beautiful and inspiring masterpiece that was John Williams' "The Patriot", from earlier this year. But two 5 star + scores in one year is pretty amazing, and "The Patriot"'s greatness does nothing to diminish the greatness that is "The Legend of Bagger Vance"!
|