|
|
14 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A Fair Summary with some nice bonuses, January 14, 2001
I'll be the first to admit that I loathed the premise behind Survivor. For all it's "real life, uncensored drama," it was still an incredibly manipulative, voyeuristic program. I got hooked on the show by the third week, when the various survivor names started sticking in my mind with the various survivor faces and personalities. If anyone made it far enough in this series to have favorites, they were fans, whether they admit it or not. Now that the show is revered as "the" reality TV event of 2000 (and not reviled, like Big Brother or the wretched Who Wants To Marry A Millionaire), viewers who were too 'principled' to watch the show faithfully can turn to this DVD for the rest of the story. Those of us who became ravenous fans may find ourselves slightly disappointed with this compilation of "greatest" and "most outrageous" moments.The structure of this compilation is fairly straightforward: viewers are given a slightly expanded view of the pre-island days, and after establishing the basic premise of the two teams (and setup of the two camps), we go straight into the eliminations. Each survivor gets their own "chapter" on DVD, in the order of their departures from competition. These chapters highlight the social standing of each contestant, just prior to losing at tribal council. The soon to be banished survivor's pre-selection interview and "demo tape" is spliced in with footage of them in various "notable" social interactions. These are also the chapters in which continuity is ignored, and occasionally an already banished survivor appears, in interaction with the victim-to-be. Some of the "heavier" moments are highlighted, though virtually every minor alliance and casual friendship wound up on the cutting room floor. That's the problem with taking 14+ hours of televised footage and straining it down to manageable 2 hour feature. But don't worry that your favorite survivor's personality has been whitewashed: Stacy still comes off as snide, Gervase's lazy charm is in force, etc. The survivors who lasted longest get the most exposure, of course. Speaking of 'exposure,' parents can need not worry about the nudity warning that flashes onscreen before the program begins: there are half a dozen fanny shots (mostly Richard) that never made it to TV. (Oh yeah...nice butt, Greg!) Profanity is probably the only objectionable material here, since there are some four letter words that made the final cut. For sheerly disgusting moments, nothing beats the fish-thing Richard catches, which starts to melt into slime the minute he cuts it open. Yes, even worse than the larvae eating sequence. Of the many Survivor-related conversations I've had at work, it seems like a lot of people questioned "actual" personalities versus "televised" personalities. No one can say how each survivor adapted their "normal" speech and activities for the sake of TV (remember Greg & Colleen's fake fling?), but the way in which producers "arranged" and scored material to achieve a certain impact with TV audiences is reinforced here. Again, some of the survivors (Sonja, BB, Ramona) register only nominal personalities, but many of the others were shown to audiences cast in the light of the producer's eyes. So much of the "total" experience is edited that this DVD will reinforce the stereotypical character traits associated with each survivor...rather than show you a side of their personalities you didn't see when the show aired. The bonuses on this disc are fairly interesting. There's a section of survivor bios (still frame reading) and voting histories, a map of survivor island and it's environs, a bit about the climate, vegetation and wildlife on the island, and a few other goodies. The 'documentary' piece is a worthwhile extra, featuring narratives from host Jeff Probst and series creator Mark Bennett. No, neither of them tells us who their favorite survivors were, but Probst' enthusiasm for the show makes his hokey host routine easier to bear. In spite of some over-familiarity and unavoidably massive editing, this Survivor compilation is probably a must-own for fans. It's also a worthwhile 'document' in regard to television history, no less remarkable for it's manipulative premise. -Stoned Soul
|