|
|
20 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Exquisite, Of Course, But More of the Same, March 23, 2001
It's hard to fault this album: Towner's playing on this solo guitar recording is exquisite, full of sensitivity, quiet passion, and an "almost Asian sense of balance," as a New York Times critic put it sometime ago. There is no doubt that this is music that will be listened to in 500 years -- after three decades of fine recordings like this, Towner has practically become his own idiom, his own "classical" music. "Solitary Woman" is a retitling of "Alia's Theme" from Towner's wonderful soundtrack to the Italian film "Un Altra Vita," and this is an excellent, brooding version. The reading of the great Scott LaFaro tune "Gloria's Step" is likewise sublime, even if it doesn't add much to the version Towner recorded on the Oregon album "Moon and Mind." Similarly, "Goodbye Pork Pie Hat" is all well and good, but doesn't add more than Towner's intimitable control and subtlety to the hundreds of covers of this tune. The sound here, of course, is the total top-drawer ECM diamond-cutter treatment, with every harmonic and heart-rending shading glittering and precise. Any lover of solo guitar music should love this record -- and fans of, say, Bach's lute music should give it a listen if they want to expand into contemporary territory. So, why didn't I give it the five stars it would deserve, if judged against anyone else's recordings? Because it's slightly boring, my friends. Towner's last ECM venture was another solo guitar excursion, "Ana," which I also found a bit enervated. I'm not prejudiced against solo guitar music -- Towner's "Solo Concert" is one of my favorite albums; but compared to "Solo Concert," "Anthem" seems a little tired and precious. Towner shines and swings in response to other instrumental risk-takers, as in the Oregon group, or on that terribly underrated masterpiece, "Batik," playing in the company of Eddie Gomez and Jack DeJohnette. His previous solo work -- such as "Diary" and "Blue Sun" -- used keyboards, percussion, and varying guitar textures to maintain textural interest. The "Un Altra Vita" soundtrack pushed in many directions while retaining a single mood -- as do all of Towner's best recordings. I feel unfair complaining about music this refined, this lovely, this mature, but I wish Manfred Eicher would push Towner a little, instead of building one crystalline vitrine after another for the Towner Museum. As they say on the street, Towner needs to get out more.
|