|
19 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Sent mine back, August 6, 2001
I really wanted to like the G-30, but in the end I returned it.My family has a number of FRS radios which we use at shopping malls, trips to the zoo, big conventions and outings to amusement parks. I wanted something with a little more "oomph" and on less crowded frequencies, so I got a GMRS license. In looking for a smallish GMRS capable handheld, I gave the G-30 a try. First. This radio is advertised as FRS/GMRS which is misleading. This is not an FRS radio, it requires an FCC issued GMRS license to operate on any of its channels - even the first seven which are shared with the FRS radios. Keep in mind this radio does not work on FRS channels 8-14. The ... advertising blurb omits mention of the fact that a GMRS license is required. This is not a big deal since it only involes an online application at www.fcc.gov and the payment of a fee. No test is required. There are some good features to the G30. Small size - on the same order as many FRS radios. I can see my wife agreeing to tote one around. Simple operation - given that this a simplex only radio, this is definitely a set and forget kind of radio. A few key presses and you can easily set the channel and ctcss tones. Rechargeable batteries and drop in charger are included. Now the bad. Poor quality belt clip. The belt clip popped off if the radio is dropped because it fits very loosely into its bracket. The belt clip does not inspire confidence that it will stay put during normal use. Non-rugged design. I managed to drop the radio about 24 inches to a wooden floor while sitting at my desk. I expected the case to crack, although it did not. The plastic used in the case seems unlikely to me to survive a drop from wist height onto concrete or stone. Although I was not expecting industrial bulletproof construction, I was hoping for a radio I wouldn't be afraid would break if my 7 year old dropped it or my 3 year old tossed it out of the grocery cart. Although the radio is advertised as "water resistant" there is no reason to believe that it really is. The manufacturer does not appear to have taken any particular precautions to keep water out. The biggest problems related to the way its features were implemented. Scanning is available on this radio. The problem is that the radio pauses only a very brief (non-adjustable) time after a transmission ends before resuming scanning making it possible that the radio will have resumed scanning before the reply comes. Also, there is no way to jump to a channel found by scanning. For example, suppose you set your radio to use channel 11. if you set the radio to scan and find a conversation you'd like to join on channel 5, you would have to reset your radio to channel 5. Pressing the transmit button puts you back on channel 11, not channel 5 where you were just listening. Also, the squelch setting is non-adjustable as far as I can tell. The radio I received seemed to have squelch set a little low, resulting in random electrical noise breaking squelch on a regular basis. Note the ... description says that squelch is adjustable, it does not appear to be so and the instruction book makes no mention of any way to adjust squelch. While I did not rigorously measure this, the radio appears to be susceptible to overloading from strong signals on adjacent frequencies. A strong police department transmitter (not on a GMRS frequency) would often be heard on my radio. The radio takes a battery pack, rather than individual cells. If you ever need to replace the battery pack, you would have to buy a replacement pack, rather than individual cells. Given that this radio is enjoing what appears to be limited distribution, a replacement battery pack may be hard to come by in a year or two. (granted it is possible to have battery packs rebuilt, and this one should be easy to rebuild). In the end I decided that there were enough things I did not like about this radio that it wasn't worth keeping. Keep in mind, that if you do not intend to scan and sturdy design is not an issue then this is an OK radio. I am just not sure that I think it is worth $... in any event. For only a little more, there are more capable and sturdier radios available.
|