|
|
40 of 46 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Four stars for story, minus one for quality..., November 22, 2001
Any fantasy fan worth his or her salt has read Tolkien's masterpiece, starting with "The Hobbit." Rankin-Bass does a passable movie adaptation, but I'm also doing a review of the DVD as well.Bilbo Baggins is a mild-mannered little hobbit living unobtrusively in Bag End, a conventional hobbit-hole in the comfortably boring Shire. His life is abruptly turned upside-down when the mysterious wizard Gandalf arrives, along with thirteen dwarves (who proceed to take over Bilbo's home). That evening, they reveal their reason for coming: They are seeking a "burglar" to help them retake back Lonely Mountain, a dwarf stronghold taken over by the dragon Smaug. Whether he likes it or not, Bilbo soon ends up the burglar. The dangerous road ahead of him draws out reserves of courage and intelligence that few knew he had, and brings him to a fateful meeting that will later help shape the future of Middle-Earth. It's a pretty good adaptation, if you don't mind the omission of such things as the Arkenstone and Beorn the bear-man. Most of the essentials are here: goblins (orcs), eagles, hobbits, dwarves, treasure, Gollum and his precious, elves and wood-elves, the men of Dale, the gray wizard Gandalf, and many, many more. There are definite flaws, aside from the few omissions. For example, Rankin-Bass don't seem to like non-human-non-hobbit species: The only good elf we see is Elrond, and the other elves in Rivendell are reduced to singing voices. Similarly, we hear that Thorin's cousin Dain has arrived with a dwarf army to combat the wood-elves and men -- but we never see Dain, or any other dwarves except the thirteen. In addition, the sound for this DVD is TERRIBLE. They have cleaned it up in places, but in other areas they have inserted gratuitous screams and mutters. They have also pulled out sounds: barrels rolling, arrows striking, Smaug roaring and breathing fire, the dwarves wailing from inside their barrels, the clash of gates - you get the idea. It's little details that makes it feel more real, but these are all removed from the DVD version. There is also an annoying crackling sound that pops up every now and then, obscuring some of the dialogue. The animation is pretty odd-looking, but you grow used to it. It was also slightly strange that we see almost nothing of the battle or of anyone being wounded - we see strange facial expressions and schizophrenic spinning motions, but nothing else; we are also treated to the weird sight of the Elf-King, Bard, and Thorin all gushing over each other, ten seconds after they were trying to kill each other. On the flipside, the soundtrack is excellent, drawing sometimes from Tolkien's songs or dialogue. Anyhow, you may wish to watch this movie in preparation for the start of Peter Jackson's stellar live-action trilogy. Obviously it isn't as high-quality, but it gives the necessary backstory into Bilbo and the Ring, and is a pleasant movie to watch.
|