|
|
13 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good performance - a pain to get up and running, June 12, 2002
A month ago, I bought the SMC SMC2655W Wireless Access Point to provide access for my laptop to my small, in-home Ethernet. I use an Orinoco silver card with the laptop. I read many reviews concerning the performance of this combination, and I made the purchase based stricktly on the performance issue.It's a good thing that I am an experienced network tech, because getting the SMC unit to work with my existing 3com ISDN router and ethernet was not easy. To start with, my router provides DHCP services to all connected workstations. However, the SMC AP didn't seem to respond properly as a DHCP client no matter what I did. Even after I did the firmware upgrade, it made no difference. In the end, I was forced to turn off DHCP on my router, manually set up the IP table in the router, and assign hard IP addresses to every device. To initially access the SMC AP to make the necessary adjustments to it, I was forced to make up a crossover CAT 5 cable and plug the AP directly into a PC to configure it. Also, even though I upgraded the manager software that comes with the AP, it still cannot find the AP automatically on the network. I have to give the manager the IP address of the AP before it can find it. Oh, yes. Don't count on much help from SMC beyond the average front-line phone tech help dummy. After I called SMC, they were ready to tell me that the unit was defective. I had already determined that it wasn't, so I proceeded without their "help" after they couldn't explain to me why it was defective. After finally bringing the SMC online, the actual operation was flawless and performance was beyond my expectations. There is nowhere in my house or out in my yard that I can't get a full signal according to my Orinoco card monitoring software. I live on a large farm, so I decided to actually test out the range. I found that I could actually still get a medium signal and 5mbs transfer rate at over 1000 feet as long as I could maintain clear line-of-site between the SMC AP and the Orinoco card in my laptop. I could also get a full signal and 11mbs as far away as 600 feet. No doubt the SMC has a hot radio. I even read that there was info on the web that shows how to tweak even more power out of it. However, I don't consider the installation I had to perform to be a task for the average plug-and-play user. That is why I rated the unit a 4 out of a possible 5. If the software, DHCP client sevices, and tech support were better, I would rate this unit a 10!
|