|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great stuff, with a couple of minor flaws., March 21, 2002
This review is from: Concerto Suite for Electric Guitar and Orchestra in E flat minor LIVE (Audio CD)
First of all, I'm a major fan of Yngwie's music both as a joy to listen to, and exciting to use as a teaching tool (I'm learning guitar and my teacher uses a lot of Yngwie's stuff to demonstrate ideas in Classical playing and obscure bits of theory), and I loved the original studio version of the Concerto Suite. I think that this new version is as good, but certainly not better than the studio cut. This could have been an absolutely awesome CD, but instead it is mearly a pretty good one. The main problem is the acoustic and volumatic problems, that the other reviews have mentioned. When this was recorded at the Shibuya Orchard Hall in Tokyo, it had to be done in a slightly different matter than a normal orchestrial concert. In order to get the volume and tone he wanted Yngwie had to use more amplification than the orchestra itself could overcome. So as to not have the orchestra drowned out, the engineers working on the show cleverly filtered and amplified the orchestra using the Halls state of the art PA and speaker system. However by doing this they created a different type of acoustic dynamic and enviornment than a standard classical concert setting. Because it was different than a normal concert's acoustics it caused problems when it came time to mixing it using the classical standard 24-bit recording. This type of recording is best when done in a completely acousitc manner, when any amplification takes place it must be acounted for and balanced out in the mixing. With all the types of amplification going on, it is quite obvious that they overcompensate in spots, and mixed it too low in others. It is a glaring error on their part for not recording in the manner of a more traditional high volume concert, but overall it doesn't hurt the overall quality of the CD as much as you would think. Overall its a decent CD, but if your going to import look for the DVD the sound mix is much better, especailly if you have a decent Dolby Digital system and there is another extra track on it. Not to mention the piece has more impact seeing it performed, as opposed to just hearing it.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|