|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Catchy...but no Morning Glory...nice "hidden" track, though, July 16, 2002
To me, Oasis' zenith was (What's the Story) Morning Glory?, an album that contains quite a few of my all-time favorite Oasis songs. (The title track being one.)Standing On the Shoulder of Giants wasn't all that bad, but it certainly was no Morning Glory. Heathen Chemistry is a cross between Morning Glory and Giants. It contains an abundance of signature Oasis riffs and lots of melodic passages. It's immediately accesible from the opening track ("The Hindu Times"). And it even features a beautiful ballad in the form of "She is Love" -- one of the prettiest, most non-cynical songs I've heard from the Gallaghers in a long time. Sure, Oasis sounds reminiscent of the Beatles -- but not lyrically, nor in the chord progressions of their songs. (I think the Beatles actually used more chords.) If anything, they sounds like the Beatles in their Britishness and attitude. Frankly, there's not a song on Heathen Chemistry I could put my finger on and say, "Yeah, that's the Beatles." So, let's lay off the Beatles comparisons, for Pete's sake! Speaking of the chord progressions, they're big, big big on Heathen Chemistry. That trademark wall of sound that I liked so much on Morning Glory is all over Heathen Chemistry. (Check out "Hung in a Bad Place," track three.) Liam is in fine vocal form. Noel is as deft as ever with his guitar work. "Songbird" is another pretty track. Acoustic guitars, tamborine, piano, and other non-typical Oasis instruments make this another stand-out track for me. Great song. "A Quick Peep" is a driving tune with lots of heavy bass, organ, acoustic guitar and a groove I'm going to enjoy watching in concert (if they play this track!). "Better Man," the last track, is a guitar-heavy rocker of the old school that's a great way to close the album. It, too, has a cool groove that keeps pushing the song forward to the final feedback-laden fade-out at about 4:18...and then falls silent for about another 30 minutes...returning with something entirely different at 33:13 after someone says, "...two, three, four." I wonder how many people have sat through the Gallagher's 30 minutes of silence to discover this "hidden" musical interlude buried way, way deep on the disc? (It's kind of a haunting "song," though, about four minutes in length. Worth hearing, even given the interminable wait.) Let's put this in perspective. Track 11 is nearly 40 minutes in length, with only about seven minutes of actual music, separated by about 33 minutes of silence. In other words, Heathen Chemistry clocks in at 76 minutes, but there's only about 40 minutes worth of music on it. Clever? Or exasperating? You be the judge. Heathen Chemistry is trademark Oasis. If you like a British attitude, clever chord progressions, a lead singer with a terminally nasal, raspy voice, and songs with lyrics that usually twist the knife in a cynical, albeit clever way, you can't go wrong with the latest CD from Oasis. But if you *really* want to be blown away, pick up a copy of (What's the Story) Morning Glory? That's a classic.
|