Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
25 of 26 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
St. Lesbos Fire., August 16, 2005
I gave this movie a 1, but it's a 5 on the unintentional comedy scale. There is enough stilted dialogue, cliches and bad acting in this movie to embarrass William Shatner.
There were some strange things going on in this movie:
-> Even though the women are at a casual writer's retreat out in the woods, they all dress up exactly like they would back home. Why? So you can decipher their personalities in a hurry, without a lot of messy character development. I especially like how the Doctor dresses up every morning to sit at her typewriter. Nice shoulder pads!
-> Clair doesn't write a word the entire movie. She drinks, smokes, stares out the window, smokes some more, drinks a lot more, takes some aspirin, makes coffee, and then stares out the window some more. To break up the monotony, she occasionally walks on the beach and smokes. And she goes into town to drink and smoke.
-> The two main characters almost have sex 26 times. By the time they finally do it, you don't care.
-> One character states "sex between two women is about as raw as it gets." Maybe, but then why does Clair still have her jeans on during most of the final scene?
Instead of returning this movie to the public library, I decided to be a humanitarian and I ran it over with my car. Pay it forward.
|
|
|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Flawed, yes, but probably my favorite lesbian film ever, August 7, 2005
Claire of the Moon is not for everyone, as you can tell by the first time Claire (Trisha Todd) opens her mouth. She speaks slowly, with far too many "dramatic" pauses, and enunciates everything too much. We are painfully aware that she is acting. Then the woman she meets answers her back in exactly the same earnestly overacted way. It's not just Claire. My first thought was "Uh-oh, the entire movie is going to be like this?" And it is. There's some really awful lines and bad acting, and it can feel awfully slow. But, believe it or not, it is good. You stop noticing the stilted acting after a while.
This film is the story of Claire, who, while attending a women's writing retreat, rooms with Noel, and discovers that she isn't quite as straight as she thinks she is. This love story is intertwined with meetings with the other women at the writing retreat, ostensibly to discuss their novels, but really to talk about gender and relationships.
Claire of the Moon is very much a product of its time, with a lot more separatism than is currently fashionable. This movie is entirely about women -- there is pretty much one speaking male character in the movie, with a very minor part, and any other men are there as objects. Relationships between women are privileged; the idea that men and women speak different languages and will never understand each other is prominent. True intimacy (again, it was the early 90s, so substitute "love" or "sex" as appropriate) can pretty only be achieved by women, with women. You have to have a bit of the lesbian separatist in you to enjoy this, but if you do, then you really will -- it's all about women and women's community. Okay, so Noel's views on intimacy occasionally contradict themselves, but the film's heart is in the right place.
It's also a very, very pretty film. The soundtrack is full of beautiful piano pieces, some original, some Chopin, as well as some folk and rock pieces for the bar scenes. The camera work itself is unremarkable, but it doesn't need to do anything special, because the scenery is absolutely stunning. It was filmed in the Pacific Northwest, and there are many, many gorgeous shots of the Pacific. Claire walks along the beach a lot, and well she should -- it's fantastic.
Of course, the heart of the movie is the love story between Claire and Noel. Maybe I'm just biased because I think Trisha Todd is so amazingly beautiful, but I think this is one of the most convincing falling-in-love (or at least lust) lesbian movies. Watching this, I can actually believe that they want each other, which is something that I can rarely see in movies. Props to the director and the actors. The movie also does an excellent job with the sexual tension -- with all their flirting and fantasizing, you really, really start wanting Claire and Noel to get together by about the last third of the movie.
The sex scene, by the way, is my favorite one out of all the lesbian films I've seen. And not just because Claire's hot. It, unlike many others, is convincing and real and happily does not feel objectifying or exploitative. It's not one of those scenes where the women are writhing about such that the viewer wonders exactly how they're having such a good time when they're very clearly not touching each other. I can't be the only person who hates those. The scene here is so much more believable. ("Sex between women is as raw as it gets," Noel says at one point (yes, I snickered too), and the film certainly tries to live up to that.) You should at least rent it for the ending, even if you watch nothing else.
My main complaint is with whoever did the sound. It's hideously unbalanced. You have to turn the volume way up for any talking to be audible (and even then there are some lines I just can't get), and then way down for any music, which for some reason is very loud. Keep your volume control in hand. To compound the problem, there are no closed captions, so you can't just leave the sound low and follow along.
The DVD release is very nice indeed, a 2-disc special edition. There is a commentary track with the writer/director and the producer, which I recommend, and not just because it's something to listen to if you can't take listening to one character's painfully fake Southern accent during the book club meetings. From the commentary I learned that the director was sleeping with Trisha Todd, which I feel explains way more about the movie, like why the camera loves Claire naked. Anyway. On the second disc there is a making-of documentary that is almost as long as the film, and is, alas, mostly unwatchable. It is even harder to hear than the movie. There's a lot of home-movie footage of things that were probably funny to the crew but mean nothing to me, footage of cast parties, 20 minutes of the most boring outtakes ever, some cool deleted scenes, and, for some reason, every scene of topless Claire from the movie. There's also some trailers and such. If you liked the movie, the making-of is fun in a painfully bad way.
Claire of the Moon is a classic lesbian movie. I am aware of all of its flaws, and yet it is the movie I keep watching. If you're willing to be a staunch separatist for a couple hours, and can ignore some painful dialogue and occasionally clunky acting, you just might find you like Claire and Noel.
|
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
I AM OBSESSED WITH THIS MOVIE, November 6, 2004
I'm beginning to think that I may need therapy to get a handle on this one. I pretty much watch this movie on a daily basis (twice sometimes). What is it about watching Claire and Noel interact and fall in love that intrigues me so much? Your guess is as good as mine. What I am clear on is that I love the actors, the acting, the dialog, and of course, the music, which is just awesome. "Cynara, Poetry in Motion" (on DVD) is on my wish list. Keep rolling them out Nicole Conn.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
DVD ~ Henry Czerny
DVD ~ Dreya Weber
DVD ~ Diane Gaidry
DVD ~ Wendy Crewson
DVD ~ Piper Perabo
Visit our huge selection of magazine subscriptions often to see the latest special offers and bonuses. Check out magazines like
The New Yorker,
Wired, and
Vanity Fair. 
