Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
72 of 76 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Steve Earle's Finest Hour, November 27, 2002
There has been massive criticism coupled with "musical hysteria," concerning the song "John Walker's Blues." Way before the CD titled "Jerusalem" was released, DJs and music critics alike were sitting in judgment of Steve Earle's patriotism. Because the song is written from the perspective of John Walker Lindh, an American youth who recently pleaded guilty to assisting the Taliban in Afghanistan, many spoke Earle's name in the same breath with traitor. "It celebrates and glorifies a traitor to this country," screamed Steve Gill, morning host on WTN-FM. He and others DJ's around the country called for a boycott of the album. With no airplay and lack of availability at stores, their mission would be successful. What has been pushed to the wayside is the following burning question: Is the song any good or is it just another lame attempt at marketing a dull CD? The answer is simple. This particular tune, though controversial, is good, the CD damn good, and there is a great big difference between explaining a person's actions and just glorifying them. Steve Earle has many better songs on his current release "Jerusalem," especially the hauntingly beautiful duet with none other than EmmyLou Harris during "I Remember You." Nevertheless, it is the track of "John Walker's Blues" that will continue to draw the most attention to this CD. Earle presents Walker's views without passing any kind of judgment. He becomes the troubled young man, searching for answers to questions that he is unable to find in American ideology. Earle stands in Lindh's shoes and views the world from his eyes only. Steve has done this many times before in his long career. He has become a convicted murderer, ready to take that long walk, "the green mile," to the electric chair in "Billy Austin." He is a coal miner, at times lost in his own despair, on the acclaimed CD "The Mountain," recorded with bluegrass greats The Del McCoury Band. Becoming the subject of tunes is nothing new for Earle, just his own way of telling the story and making his art work. "What Earle is doing is what good songwriters...and good poets have been doing for a hundred years, which is trying to get inside and understand the motivations of people who may not be particularly popular right now," said Charles Wolfe, a popular-music scholar at Middle Tennessee State University. "There's nothing all that unique about Earle's song," he continues, "except that emotions about the Taliban are very strong right now." Earle himself has backed up Wolfe's opinion by stating the following in a press release: "I don't condone what he (Lindh) did. I'm trying to make clear that wherever he got to, he didn't arrive there in a vacuum...my son Justin is almost exactly Walker's age." Here lies the key to Earle's motivation for writing such an emotional grabbing number. The singer uses his scratchy, ragged drawl to create a bleak picture of an unquestioning belief that eventually led to dire consequences:"We came to fight the Jihad.....as death filled the air.... And prepared for our martyrdom. But Allah has some other plan... Now they're draggin me back, With my hands in a sack To the land of the infidel." Calling America the "infidel" here is the exact reason that many have reacted with outrage. However, it is a colossal mistake to confuse Steve Earle's personal views with his lyrical references. He has called "Jerusalem" "....the most pro-American record in my entire career." Questioning the idea that politicians deserve our undying support, when it comes to serious issues (like terrorism), is very American to Earle. The 'blind faith' of many over zealous so-called patriots is what seems to scare Earle the most these days. He laments in "Amerika v.6.0 (The Best We Can Do)": "I remember when we was...talkin' revolution... Nowadays letters to the editor and cheatin' on our taxes is the best that we can do." Doing what he has done best since the impact of "Guitar Town" in 1985, Steve Earle has been a vital force in American music. Always unafraid to broach sensitive issues, from murder and the death penalty to drug dealing, he continues to make those who will listen, THINK and QUESTION. Instead of taking the safe, sappy route of mainstream Nashville, he approaches issues that are unpopular to address, but necessary. While the goal of many current artists is simply to sell lots of product and make tons of money, Steve Earle makes music that is relevant, poignant and vital. His artistic integrity has never been stronger or more intact than with this current release.
|
|
|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not as Political as I expected, September 27, 2002
When I heard that Steve Earle's next record was going to be "very political", I got worried. Not because I disagreed with Earle's politics, or because I don't like political songs, or even because I don't like Earle's political songs. The reason I was worried was that I expected it to be forced; which I expected might limit the focus Earle would put on the music and lessen the quality of his lyrics. I WAS WRONG!!What I got when I played the CD was a record fairly similar to my other Steve Earle records. No, its not a retread of old ideas musically or lyrically, but its a hodgepodge of styles with some topical lyrics and some thoughtful, but not necessarily political lyrics. The CD starts with Ashes to Ashes, which is only political in that it espouses the world view that nothing is permanent, especially political empires, including this one (USA). It opens withe the whispered phrase, "Ashes to Ashes, Dust to Dust" and repeats this refrain throughout in a fine rock song. Next up is another rock song, Amerika v.6.0 which uses the Stones riff from Jumpin Jack Flash to fine effect in another song which is among the more political on the cd. Its basically a lament that this country is failing to live up to its high ideals...the best we can do, being the somewhat sarcastic refrain. This is a great song, maybe the best on the record. Conspiracy Theory is a nice rnb song with some somewhat surprising female lead vocals on the chorus which at first seem out of place, but on repeated listenings begin to grow on you. John Walker's Blues is the notorious song about the so-called American Taliban. It is a haunting ballad which puts you into Walker's head without trying to tell the listener how to feel about the subject. It's controversy is obviously overplayed and the song itself is striking musically as well. The Kind is a low key song which is probably my favorite. Its typical Earle, but again its really not political. The only other song which appears on the surface to be political is the title track, which is actually a pop song about the hope for peace in Jerusalem, and by implication, the world; kind of a modern day Imagine. If radio had any taste whatsoever, this would be a hit single. The rest of the songs are really not very political; I Remember You: a gorgeous duet with Emmylou Harris; The Truth: a haunting song from the perspective of a prisoner, written for the so-called West Memphis 3; Go Amanda: a Stonesy rocker, co written by Sheryl Crow; What's a Simple Man to Do: a tex-mex, Sir Douglas Quintet inspired song about a man who is caught smuggling drus across the mexican border. Its a terrific album, all in all. I'll readily admit to being a big Earle fan, and I'm not sure I'd put it as high on a pedestal as his most recent 3 traditional releases, Transcendental Blues, El Corazon and I Feel Alright. (I'm not counting Sidetracks, which is a terrific odds and sods collection or The Mountain, which is an outstanding bluegrass collaboration with the Del McCoury Band). If you like your rock with a southern accent and you like a variety of musical styles, you should have all 4 of Earle's latest, including this one. Steve Earle is on quite a run. Enjoy it while it lasts.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Jerusalem is one amazing song!, April 14, 2004
I like everything Steve Earle does. So it comes as no surprise that I like this album too. But the one song that stands out above all others for me is "Jerusalem." If you have any interest whatsoever in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict this song plumbs it to the depths. Almost no singer-songwriters (except Israelis) have attempted to write about the conflict & I feel enormous gratitude to Earle for taking the subject on and doing it such justice.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|