|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
continues his recent form, but still too short a CD, October 28, 2002
By A Customer
First the bad news. This CD, like many of Mathis's recent releases, is short weight. That, and that alone, prevents it from being considered five star material. He is well capable of filling a seventy four minute disc, and this CD doesn't cut it from that point of view.Now the good. Mathis remains the pre-eminent singer of the crooning category. On this album he has created further definitive versions of Christmas Classics to add to his already impressive list. The weakest song on the album is the new one - Heavenly Peace. Whether this is because it is lyrically lightweight, or heavily dependent on cheap sounding synthesisers is a matter of opinion. However, his version of Frosty the Snowman is a delight which will have you bouncing your feet. Unashamedly retro, it swings with a feeling recalling the best of Bing Crosby or Nat King Cole's Christmas recordings. Another swinger is I've Got My Love to Keep Me Warm - great tune. Mathis has abandoned the nasal quality of his early swinging material and gone for a much warmer sound. But it is on the ballads that Mathis proves he may yet be a better singer than he has ever been - incredible to be readapting at the age of 67. The clear winner on the album is A Christmas Love Song by Johnny Mandel and the Bergmans. Mathis brings sensitivity that most of today's "crooners" could only dream of. Of almost equal quality is Snowfall, a beautiful performance which obliterates all memory of the very good Tony Bennett version. The key thing is that Mathis simply sounds warmer than ever. The voice is deeper, creating that impression of depth. But it has lost none of its tone. Compared with his work of the previous decade, it is in a different league. He may well be a better phraser of a song than even Sinatra.
|