Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
24 of 24 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A great tablet PC, October 1, 2003
Tablet PC has been out almost a year now and is slowly gaining momentum in the corporate world. For the average consumer, though, I think it's still way over-priced and under-equipped in terms of software. In short, the Tablet PC platform is still largely a vertical market product.That said, having a Tablet PC does give the gadget freak a few cool things to enjoy. For example, scratch on a pad to your heart's full content. Not enough? How about watching a DVD movie at any angle you wish? Still want more? You can lie on your stomach and surf the web, you geek! The Protege 3505 is arguably the sleekest and strongest TPC on the market right now. It's a hybrid model with a keyboard which turns it into a notebook. Compared to the lower-rung 3500 model, the 3505 has more memory (512 vs. 256) and also comes with an external DVD drive. It has wi-fi built-in (along with Ethernet and IR), and depending on the specific configuration, you can opt for built-in Bluetooth as well. Performance is solid from the P3-M processor. You should know that the TPC version of Windows XP is optimized for the processors so you actually get a lot of performance at "low" clock speeds. ("Low" compared to desktop P4s; if you compare with Power PC G3 or G4's, these are still "fast".) I certainly have no problem playing MP3s in the background while running a few Excel Solver analyses; the OS remains totally responsive. Battery life is average for TPCs, but weight is where Toshiba can improve. On the other hand, this is an affordable TPC, so you have to ask yourself which of the two (weight vs. price) is more important to you. Fujitsu's Tablet PCs are better built and only slightly less sleek, but their battery life is not as good as Toshiba while costing more. Sorry, still no perfect TPC yet. Should you get your Amazon Visa card out and order one right now? I'd say no. There isn't much software included, and the novelty factor wears off quickly, plus 4.1 pounds (not counting the external DVD) is a lot to carry. On the other hand, if your company pays for it, it's another story.
|
|
|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A powerful compact laptop that *happens* to also be a tablet, June 13, 2003
I got this machine a few months ago - when they first hit the market. I was *very* excited about the TabletPC in general, and I knew I had to get one. The only question was: Which one should I get? I tried them all at length, and made the easy decision to go with the Toshiba for a few simple reasons:1) It really is a top-notch laptop. 1.3GHz, 512MB RAM, and a 40GB harddrive. It is *super* light-weight and sturdy, and fits in the smallest of bags. Even if it wasn't able to convert into a tablet, this would be a competitive laptop. 2) It had the best configuration of ports, wireless, etc. I take a *lot* of digital pictures, and there is a CF card slot right in the side of it. The internal 802.11b wireless card works flawlessly in my home and work network, making it an extremely mobile device. My mini-mouse also plugs into one of the 2 USB slots quite nicely. 3) The *giant* 12.1" screen! Yes, it sounds tiny - but it's huge for a pressure sensative tablet screen, and much larger than most of the competition. It can also plug into an external monitor and use it's screen as *extra* real-estate if you desire. The funny thing is that I use it in "laptop" mode about 90% of the time. I only use the tablet functionality to play solitaire, or to read news links online while laying in bed at night. It does a great job of recognizing handwriting to take notes in a meeting (as advertised) - but I type *much* faster than I can write with a pen anyway! Go figure. The only draw-back that I have found is that the on-board ATI graphics are a little sub-par for a high end machine like this. If Toshiba had done a deal with nVidia or something, this would be a truly smoking machine! As it turns out, however, my employer just furnished me with a brand new laptop, so I am selling mine in the "Used Item" section of this site. If it isn't listed, then I must have sold it already! Thanks for the "reach" Amazon! - Joe
|
|
|
12 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good Choice, July 14, 2003
I've only had this tablet for about a week, now, so there is still much to learn about it. However, so far it has exceeded my expectations. I purchased the Toshiba 3505 Tablet after considerable research. I have used it to write meeting minutes...the option to turn my writing into type is a huge asset. And since I print more than I handwrite, the tablet has been surprisingly accurate with the translation from writing to type. I also carry it with me at work to keep track of "To Do" lists, phone calls/conversations, employee absences, and days that we use subcontractors. The tablet is geared toward organization, and it works beautifully. It has plenty of data storage options. The DVD Drive I got is external, however, which is a bit of a hassle unpacking it and plugging it in everytime, but I only consider that a minor inconvenience since it does have the internal memory cards for storing data. The only other minor negative I have with it is that it doesn't pack with much additional software, so I've had to load it up with my work programs. All in all, I am very glad to have chosen the Toshiba.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|