|
|
85 of 87 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great sound, uninspired tracklisting, September 12, 2003
To say that the Zombies have "several" Greatest Hits compilations would be understating it just a tad; that's like saying the Who milk their fans for cash "every once in a while." This late in the game, if another entry is going to be made in the Zombies Greatest Hits pantheon, it ought to have *something* special about it and offer something previous sets haven't; otherwise, another "Great Pop Bands of the 60s" set doesn't really have an audience. Thankfully, The Zombies Greatest Hits from Audiofidelity *does* have several things going for it.For one, these twenty tracks have never sounded better. Barring some dropouts inherent in the source material, this really sounds stellar, easily beating even the Decca Stereo Anthology on some tracks (although to be fair, that set attempts to duplicate the EQ and 'verb of the original mono mixes, whereas many of the stereo mixes presented here are under no such illusion). For another, this disc is an SACD hybrid (meaning it plays on almost all regular CD players--some DVD players have trouble with hybrid discs--as well as on SACD players), and is cheap, to boot. Now, granted, many people have troubled discerning a huge "night and day" difference between the high resolution and CD layers, but it's still a nice thought, and who'd have thought the Zombies would ever be considered for a SACD entry? So yes. Enough with audiofetishism for now, and on to the music. Unfortunately, the main failing of this set is its slightly uninspired track selection. The compilers were clearly more fond of the earlier, British-invasion stylings of the group as opposed to their more developed Odessey and Oracle vibe; consequently, the vision presented of the group is a bit skewed (although in all honesty almost every Zombies comp has the same problem). I love "I Don't Want To Know" and "It's Alright With Me," but I can't help feeling that they're not necessarily the best tracks for a "Greatest Hits" compilation. Indeed, the tracklisting is very, very similar to this disc's predecessor, the DCC "Greatest Hits" compilation. However, whereas that disc actually had a unique track (the "organ intro" version of Imagine the Swan), this disc doesn't actually have anything unavailable elsewhere. Collectors who're satisfied with the quality of the DCC disc thus don't "need" this, as all of its tracks and mixes do appear elsewhere. The verdict? If you're just getting into the Zombies, I humbly suggest that one pick up a slightly more comprehensive collection. The Big Beat discs, for example, are far more attractive in track selection, cover art, and liner notes. However, the sound on this disc just can't be beat, so for the "experienced" Zombies listener, this is one Greatest Hits compilation that shouldn't be idly passed over.
|