Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
65 of 68 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Maybe a bit too honest for some, June 11, 2003
Yikes! Lucinda really split herself wide open on this one. As a huge fan of her self-titled and "Car Wheels..." releases, I struggled with the nakedness of "Essence" and grew to love it. Again, with this release, I had a hard time getting through it the first time, but it gets easier with each listen. The lyrics are sheer poetry, albeit dark, painful, poetry. And Lucinda's delivery makes them darker and even more painful. I think a first-time listener might be turned off if this were their first Lucinda Williams experience.My favorite song on this release is "Righteously". As I've played it, several people have stopped by my cubicle and asked, "What are you listening to? That song rocks!" Almost stripped down musically, it has a wailing guitar and strong bass line that moves the song along. The last line is my favorite - - "Be my lover don't play no game, Just play me John Coltrane". "Ventura" has a beautiful steel-guitar, wavy-feeling kind of sound. "Real Live Bleeding Fingers and Broken Guitar Strings" (great title!) sounds very Neil Young-ish to me. "Overtime" is classic heartbreak, almost Patsy Cline-ish...the simple drum work and the verby guitar along with the simple lyrics work beautifully well together. In most of her songs, Lucinda doesn't subscribe to the pop structure of songwriting - - stanza, chorus, stanza, repeat chorus, etc. Instead the songs are more like poems with wonderful music accentuating them. I can never decide if Lucinda's vocals are a strength or a weakness...they are often rough and "hick-ish", but they do add a substantial amount of depth to the words. While I can imagine a "better" singer singing them, I realize the song would lose so much of its impact if it were slick and smooth. I think Lucinda has come to terms with never hearing her music played on commercial radio stations across the country. Still, and admirably so, she refuses to sell out her themes and her musical style for the spoon-fed masses, and instead brings out a different kind of honesty, a different kind of love, a different kind of relationship, those not usually revealed or acknowledged in the mainstream. We're talking about abusive and drug-addicted, twisted and unhealthy relationships here. There's not very much warm and fuzzy going on. Proof that angst is a wonderful catalyst for art.
|
|
|
42 of 45 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Yet Another Classic, April 22, 2003
Judging by the reviews listed before mine, I would guess that Lucinda Williams will never acheive mega-stardom. She just doesn't seem to care about making everybody happy.Personaly, I find that WORLD WITHOUT TEARS is yet another in a series of outstanding efforts by Lucinda. It is about as different from ESSENCE as that album was from CAR WHEELS. ESSENCE, her last triumph, was a melancoly affair that found Lucinda loosening up her recording methods and vocals. WORLD seems to come from a more angry place is generally played loose and loud. ATONEMENT, BROKEN GUITAR STRINGS and RIGHTEOUSLY find her rocking more than she ever has on record. The "rap" numbers SWEET SIDE and AMERICAN DREAM sound a lot better than they look on paper (it's closer to talking blues than Jay-Z). VENTURA, FRUITS OF MY LABOR and the title track are just plain prime cuts that are more in the tradition of her earlier work. For those who complain about her vocals, I beleive that they miss the point. Lucinda's vocals are similar to Bob Dylans and Neil Youngs. They are not the perfect pitches of a Star Search competitor, but a soulful instrument that uses timing and emotion to get a song across. Her vocals are first takes on this record and are certainly raw, but infused with passion. This may, or may not be her best outing, only time will tell, but it certainly elevates her status as one of the finest musicians currently working.
|
|
|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Brave but grim, April 23, 2003
By A Customer
Following Lucinda Williams' recorded career has been like watching an eclipse gradually cover the sun, as the brightness of her early material has been gradually supplanted by darker emotions and themes. Her best work has found a balance between the dark and the light, but World Without Tears finds Lucinda in full shadow, dealing nearly exclusively in themes of loneliness, addiction, abuse, and abandonment. It makes for grim listening, despite the rough sheen and passion of the live-in-the-studio music. Williams, who once struggled for acceptance within the country establishment only to be adopted by the punkish alt.country cult, seems to actively work against any hope of radio airplay or mainstream popularity -- again dropping the f-bomb on the most radio-accessible song on the disc ("Those Three Days"), as she did on 2001's "Essence", seemingly *daring* any radio station to play it, and choosing oddball production tricks, such as vocal filtering and heavily echoplexed guitar. But despite a few graceless moments, the best songs here, including "Days" and the disc's opener, "Fruits of My Labor", retain the nuanced songwriting and expertly-shaded drawl upon which Williams made her reputation. Elsewhere, though, she too often lurches between a bellow (as on "Atonement", a gutbucket blues stomper that aims at Howlin' Wolf territory but hits Jim Morrison instead) and her Texas-flat speaking voice (as on "American Dream", a rap that takes the album's misery out of the first person and into the realm of social ills, with lyrics that even the most earnest early-80's conciousness-raising rappers would find hamfisted). Musically, this is an adventurous and even brave album. Freed from commercial expectations, Williams and her band move easily between and around genres, evoking Crazy-Horse era Neil Young one minute and Hank Williams the next, successfully dabbling as far afield as hip-hop and ambient textures while never losing sight of the Texas soil that grounds it. This is a much more textured and musically expressive album than its predecessor, Essence, and as such should reward repeated listens. Yet even as the music draws one deeper the unrelentingly sad lyrics, full of vomit and desperation, repel. This isn't even the kind of sad album you'd want to put on when *you're* sad -- there is little resonance or hope of better days ahead here, just an extended tour of Lucinda's bleak psychic landscape.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|