Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
134 of 143 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Great music, horrible presentation, November 11, 2003
By A Customer
Here's a dilemma: one of my favorite bands for the past two decades, one of the most enduring and wonderful electronic pop acts ever, releasing a sub-standard hits compilation. Yes, the music itself deserves 5 stars. But what's up with this release? I don't understand why it has been put together this way.Since their first singles compilation ("Pop!"), Erasure have released 15 more singles. Why not follow the "Pop!" blueprint and simply release those 15 in chronological order? Why do we need this new "Hits!" disc? Think about it: Erasure's massive popularity has definitely waned in the past 10 years. Who is still buying their releases? Of course, its those of us who are diehard fans. And we should be presented with better product than this. "Hits!" contains 20 tracks... 12 of which were already included on 1992's "Pop!" Of the past 15 Erasure singles released since "Pop," "Hits" provides six. SIX. How necessary was it to include three of the four "Abba-esque" tracks on this compilation? Some glaring omissions include the remixed "Who Needs Love Like That" (originally available only on the cassette-version of "Pop!"), the radio mix of "Rock Me Gently" (available only on a Czech single), the remixed version of "Don't Say Your Love Is Killing Me" (U.S.-only single mix including an entire verse of the song not included on the "Cowboy" album version). And really, do any of us need another version of "Oh L'amour?" Why mess with an 80's synth classic? The import version of "Hits!" is available with a second CD containing a "megamix" that is equally as frustrating. It contains 18 tracks and also has some missing gems. Why not replace the ballads and mid-tempo tunes (tracks 1 through 4) and replace them with some better remixes? "In My Arms" was a #2 smash on the Billboard dance chart and is not included, nor is "Don't Say Your Love Is Killing Me," another Top 5 Billboard Club hit. A real bonus would have been to include the much sought-after, promo-only Out Of the Blue remix of "Blue Savannah." On top of all this, the song-to-song transitions are sloppy and uninspiring. Erasure is one of my all-time favorite bands. I've been listening to them religiously since their debut in 1985. I'm one of the lucky few who has had the opportunity and funds to be a completist. Most of the missing tracks I mentioned above I have been able to obtain as import singles. It just would have been nice to be given an Erasure product that was a little more comprehensive and representative of their outstanding output in the past decade. Note to Mute: think of the fans next time. Give us rarities, radio remixes, B-sides and rare club re-workings. We'd be most appreciative.
|
|
|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Hits-less!, December 31, 2003
Erasure first released a greatest hits 11 years ago in 1992 titles Pop 20 Hits. Come 2003, their record company releases their second compilation, but fans may be disappointed cos out of the 20 songs, 12 were available already on Pop 20.
The CD covers the hits from 1986 - 1992 comprehensively but misses a great deal of the later work from 1994 - 2003. I Say I Say I Say is represneted by only Always while Run To The Sun and I Love Saturday are glaringly missing. From Erasure, Rock Me Gently is not included. The biggest travesty is the omission of the excellent Don't Say Your Love Is Killing Me from Cowboy.
There is a bonus CD of Erasuremegamix of 18 of the songs from Disc 1. Serves good as an icing on the cake but still, could have been better if this second CD is devoted to the 15 singles released after Pop 20. The record honchos should take a cue from Pet Shop Boy's recent anthology. This compilation just doesnt do much justice to the enegetic disposition of the band.
Buy the DVD instaead...it includes all their videos and much more extra footage.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
DISAPPOINTING, April 28, 2004
I know no one who loves Erasure more than I do. I am a die-hard fan, and buy everything they release. But I must say I am very disappointed in this . Having been released back in the fall of 2003 , I still found a "limited edition" of HITS! on the shelves of my local music store. That alone should tell you how their fan base has eroded over the years. It's a shame, really, because to my way of thinking they have released some of their best work in the last 10 or so years. It is miles ahead of their early work, in terms of production and musical quality. It is more mature and often more reflective. But to include most all of the songs found on POP! on this latest disc, at the expense of some of their later, better singles ( often singles that were remixed from their album versions - and THAT is what we Erasure fans want, hard to find things like single remixes, video remixes etc ) is just a travesty. The omissions have already been explained thoroughly in earlier posted reviews here so I won't go into specifics. But suffice to say there is SO MUCH MISSING here. And the "bonus" megamix is LAME. I hate to say so, and I am wondering if Andy and Vince heard it before they gave the go-ahead for its release. Otherwise, I see no point in its inclusion. It sounds like something you would have heard 20 years ago in a roller skating rink. It is just that bad. Sloppy edits, remixes that neither enhance nor serve the original versions... I could go on and on about why I dislike it so much. But I won't. As I said earlier, no one I know loves Erasure like I do. But I can't recommend this to fans new or old. They could have done so much better. I can however highly recommend the DVD companion to this set. Presented in it are videos that have never been on DVD, with great sound quality and a few bonus extras that are truly worth the name "bonus." Pity the CD version can not boast the same.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Erasure share their favorite music with Amazon customers. See all artists' picks on our Music You Should Hear page.
This item is part of our Music Deals Store, where you'll find extra savings on hundreds of CDs across all genres.
is one of Erasure's 
