Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
32 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Delighting the ear, Elevating the soul, October 7, 2004
This has to be my favorite Anonymous 4 album. True, it is not Hildegard von Bingen or Tavener, but this music has a beauty of its own. It is able to be both obtainable and transcendent. Talk about a paradox. It floods my heart with memories of my earthly home, while sending my soul in flight to my heavenly one.
I do not mean to put down others' opinions, but I really must object to two. First,whoever says that this music is all about the melody has obviously never heard the sound of a Primitive Church Song Meeting. IT'S ALL ABOUT THE HARMONY! Many, many times the melody, which is in the men's tenor, is almost drowned out by the ladies' treble. Singing your part out is encouraged whether you have the melody or not, and since our ear naturally hears the higher part louder, it's not unusual to lose the melody. I actually find it SO much easier to hear the melodies on this album, than in an actual meeting.
Also, those claiming that this music is not Southern are mistaken. The style may have originated in 18th cent. New England, and many of the tunes were composed by New Englanders, but since the mid-nineteenth cent. and the "Better Music" movement, these songs have been almost exclusively confined to the rural South. The most prominent of the VERY few reasons the tradition survives to this day is that it has been zealously upheld by the Old Order and other small Calvinist-Baptist sects of the Southern hills. If it was not originally Southern, it has now become so. And this recording is no where near Dixie Chicks. With this you have a wonderous reverence, with DC a 'honky-tonkism'.
I would like to say that the other major reason I love this album is because it kind of makes this music legitimate. Too long have shape-note tunes been snobbed by modern musicians; I'm glad to see that some are captured once again by its charm.
Finally,I give Anonymous 4 a standing ovation for a wonderful and successful career, and I'm sorry to see it come to an end.
|
|
|
35 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
beautiful, March 2, 2004
The critics of "American Angels" are correct in one sense: this disc is very atypical for an Anonymous 4 recording. But there is good reason for this: the songs are from an era hundreds of years later than their typical choices. So before you read any further, I should warn you that if you desire a selection of medieval or Renaissance vocal stylings, then this disc is not for you.But after over a dozen Early Music recordings, the Anonymous 4 can be forgiven for attempting something new with their swan song disc (they have since disbanded), and they did: this recording consists entirely of American spiritual music from the 18th and 19th centuries. And the results are unspeakably beautiful. In my estimation, these are some of the most beautiful recordings of American religious music ever recorded. All Anonymous 4 recordings will produce vocal music of unparalleled technical brilliance, but on this disc, their always-sonorous voices grant these traditional American hymns a rare and beautiful elegance. Please, listen to the clips and decide for yourself: I am sure you will find "American Angels" to be an absolute revelation. I know what some of you are thinking: but is this "classical music"? Well, I don't know. Perhaps this recording doesn't have a place next to your Dufay and Machaut CDs, but whatever you want to call it, I, for one, sure think it's beautiful.
|
|
|
28 of 29 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Inspiration sung from the heart., December 29, 2004
Now everyone is entitled to their opinion, but I really disagree with that review that complained about too much harmony. Harmony is just a basic fundamental of music that makes it sound beautiful and gorgeous. So why is harmony so terrible? Anonymous 4 is very harmonious and knows how to enhance the music performance. They are not absent of melody. These tunes stood out to me. Besides, if a I wanted an exact replica of how these songs sounded 150 years ago, I could have gotten a CD of a performance of by a Baptist choir. But I chose this CD because from the time I first heard this ensemble perform these songs on public radio, I was enchanted. They perform songs that are very meaningful to me, such as "Sweet Hour of Prayer" a hymn that I have treasured in my church for ages. I was very inspired by such songs as "Holy Manna" and "Amazing Grace" because they make me imagine the spiritual pioneer experience. Other meaningful treasures are "Wayfaring Stranger" and "Angel Band". I really fell in love with "Invitation"(Hark! I hear the harps eternal). They sing so beautifully and clearly that they deliver such inspirational insights in each song. It's not too different from their medieval/Renaissance albums. They are portraying the same spiritual longings just as they did with chants and motets, only in a different place and time period. Anyone who complains about this CD needs to take time to not just listen, but feel the music. Feel the way that each singer speaks from the heart. Feel the way that each singer expresses the longing fo the writer. They sing these words and tunes so sincerely.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|